RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2015 · 10 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2015 Chemistry question — Group 17: halogens and hydrogen halides

The least number of oxyacids are formed by:

SOLUTION

We first recall that an oxyacid is an acid which contains the element hydrogen bonded to oxygen, and the oxygen in turn is bonded to some other central element. Therefore the ability of an element to form oxyacids depends on two factors: the element should be able to bond simultaneously with oxygen and also have available orbitals (generally d-orbitals) or lower electronegativity so that it can accommodate multiple bonding.

Now we examine, one by one, the four elements given in the options and count how many oxyacids each of them is known to form.

We have chlorine. Chlorine belongs to the same group as fluorine but it possesses empty 3d-orbitals and a moderate electronegativity. It is able to expand its octet and show variable oxidation states +1,+3,+5,+7+1, +3, +5, +7. Hence chlorine forms the four well-known oxyacids: hypochlorous acid HOClHOCl, chlorous acid HClO2HClO_2, chloric acid HClO3HClO_3 and perchloric acid HClO4HClO_4. So chlorine contributes a count of 44 distinct oxyacids.

Next we consider fluorine. Fluorine is the most electronegative element (χF=4.0\chi_{F}=4.0 on the Pauling scale) and is restricted to the small 2p2p valence shell; it has no available d-orbitals. Being so electronegative, fluorine strongly withdraws electron density from oxygen, making the O−FO-F bond extremely unstable when hydrogen is also present. Consequently fluorine is unable to stabilise any compound that can be written in the general oxyacid form H−O−FH-O-F or F−O−(something)F-O-(something). In other words fluorine forms no oxyacids at all. The only common acid of fluorine is hydrofluoric acid HFHF, and that does not contain oxygen, so it is not an oxyacid. Therefore the tally for fluorine is 00.

Now we look at sulphur. Sulphur lies in Period 33, possesses empty 3d3d orbitals and shows a wide variety of oxidation states such as +2,+4,+6+2, +4, +6. Because of this versatility sulphur forms many oxyacids, for example sulphurous acid H2SO3H_2SO_3 and sulphuric acid H2SO4H_2SO_4 in the simple series, as well as peroxymonosulphuric acid H2SO5H_2SO_5 (Caro’s acid), peroxydisulphuric acid H2S2O8H_2S_2O_8 (Marshall’s acid), thiosulphuric acid H2S2O3H_2S_2O_3 and several others. Even the most conservative list gives at least 55 distinct sulphur oxyacids, obviously far more than chlorine and certainly more than fluorine.

Lastly we have nitrogen. Nitrogen has no d-orbitals but it still manages two very common oxyacids because of its moderate electronegativity and ability to form π\pi-bonds with oxygen. These are nitrous acid HNO2HNO_2 with nitrogen in oxidation state +3+3 and nitric acid HNO3HNO_3 with nitrogen in oxidation state +5+5. Besides those, hyponitrous acid H2N2O2H_2N_2O_2 and peroxynitric acid HNO4HNO_4 are also known, so nitrogen’s count is at least 33 or 44, again larger than fluorine’s.

Collecting all these counts we have:

Chlorine:4 oxyacidsFluorine:0 oxyacidsSulphur:≥5 oxyacidsNitrogen:≥3 oxyacids\begin{aligned} \text{Chlorine} & : 4 \text{ oxyacids} \\ \text{Fluorine} & : 0 \text{ oxyacids} \\ \text{Sulphur} & : \ge 5 \text{ oxyacids} \\ \text{Nitrogen} & : \ge 3 \text{ oxyacids} \end{aligned}

Clearly the smallest number is 00, which belongs to fluorine. Thus, among the elements listed, fluorine forms the least number of oxyacids.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Group 17: halogens and hydrogen halides. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGroup 17: halogens and hydrogen halides
TypeMultiple choice