RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 09 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Acidity and basicity of organic compounds

The increasing order of basicity for the following intermediates is (from weak to strong):

Figure for JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question on Acidity and basicity of organic compounds
SOLUTION
image
  1. Electronegativity and Hybridization:

    As the s-character of a carbon atom increases (sp3=25%\text{sp}^3 = 25\%, sp2=33.3%\text{sp}^2 = 33.3\%, sp=50%\text{sp} = 50\%), its electronegativity increases. A more electronegative atom holds its lone pair of electrons more tightly, making it more stable and less willing to donate them to a proton (less basic). Therefore, basicity follows the order:

    sp3-hybridized C−>sp2-hybridized C−>sp-hybridized C−\text{sp}^3\text{-hybridized C}^- > \text{sp}^2\text{-hybridized C}^- > \text{sp-hybridized C}^-
  2. Inductive Effect (+I+I):

    Alkyl groups are electron-donating groups via the +I+I effect. In sp3\text{sp}^3 carbanions, the presence of electron-donating methyl groups increases electron density on the negative carbon, increasing its tendency to donate electrons and making it highly basic.


Detailed Stability and Basicity Breakdown:

  • (v) CN−(v)\text{ }\text{CN}^- (Cyanide ion): The negative charge resides on a highly electronegative nitrogen atom, and the carbon is sp\text{sp}-hybridized. This is exceptionally stable, making it the weakest base.
  • (iii) HC≡C−(iii)\text{ }\text{HC}\equiv\text{C}^- (Acetylide ion): The negative charge is on an sp\text{sp}-hybridized carbon (50%50\% s-character). It holds the charge tightly, making it a weak base.
  • (ii) CH2=CH−(ii)\text{ }\text{CH}_2=\text{CH}^- (Vinyl carbanion): The negative charge is on an sp2\text{sp}^2-hybridized carbon (33.3%33.3\% s-character). It is more basic than sp\text{sp} but less basic than sp3\text{sp}^3.
  • (iv) CH3−(iv)\text{ }\text{CH}_3^- (Methyl carbanion): An sp3\text{sp}^3-hybridized carbanion (25%25\% s-character) with no additional alkyl groups destabilizing it. It is strongly basic.
  • (i) (CH3)3C−(i)\text{ }(\text{CH}_3)_3\text{C}^- (tert-Butyl carbanion): An sp3\text{sp}^3-hybridized carbanion flanked by three electron-donating methyl groups (+I+I effect). This drastically destabilizes the negative charge, making it the most unstable intermediate and the strongest base.

Conclusion:

Combining these factors gives the following increasing order of basicity (weak to strong):

(v)<(iii)<(ii)<(iv)<(i)\mathbf{(v) < (iii) < (ii) < (iv) < (i)}

Answer: Option C

Tagged Acidity and basicity of organic compounds. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicAcidity and basicity of organic compounds
TypeMultiple choice