RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 09 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Structural isomerism in complexes

Complex X of composition Cr(H2O)6ClnCr(H_2O)_6Cl_n has a spin only magnetic moment of 3.83 B.M. It reacts with AgNO3AgNO_3 and shows geometrical isomerism. The IUPAC nomenclature of X is:

SOLUTION

We are told that the complex has the empirical composition Cr(H2O)6ClnCr(H_2O)_6Cl_n. Such a formula merely lists everything present in one “mole” of the salt; it does not tell us which chlorides are coordinated and which are present as free (counter-ion) chloride. To make this explicit, we write

Cr(H2O)6Cln  =  [Cr(H2O)6−xClx]Cl n−xCr(H_2O)_6Cl_n \;=\;[Cr(H_2O)_{6-x}Cl_x]Cl_{\,n-x}

where

x=x= number of chloride ions coordinated to chromium,

n−x=n-x= number of chloride ions lying outside the coordination sphere.

The problem gives three qualitative facts that will let us fix both xx and the oxidation state of chromium.

(1) The complex precipitates AgClAgCl on treatment with AgNO3AgNO_3. Silver ion will react only with free chloride, so n−x>0n-x>0. Hence at least one chloride must be outside the coordination sphere.

(2) The complex shows geometrical (cis-trans) isomerism. For an octahedral complex this isomerism is possible only when at least two ligands of one kind and at least two of another kind occupy the six coordination sites. With water and chloride the minimum requirement is x≥2.x\ge 2. (The ion [Cr(H2O)5Cl](3−n)[Cr(H_2O)_5Cl]^{(3-n)} would have only one chloride inside; such a species cannot give a cis-trans pair.) We therefore choose the smallest value consistent with this condition, namely x=2x=2.

With x=2x=2 the inner-sphere formula is [Cr(H2O)4Cl2]z+[Cr(H_2O)_4Cl_2]^{z+} where zz is the charge on the complex cation. Charge balance for the whole salt is obtained from

(z)+(−1)(n−x)=0    ⟹    z=n−x.\bigl(z\bigr)+\bigl(-1\bigr)(n-x)=0 \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; z=n-x.

But we have already decided that x=2x=2, so

z=n−2andoxidation state of Cr=  z+2z=n-2 \qquad\text{and}\qquad \text{oxidation state of }Cr=\;z+2 (the +2 compensates the two coordinated Cl−Cl^- ions).

(3) The spin-only magnetic moment is μobs=3.83  B.M.\mu_{\text{obs}} = 3.83\; \text{B.M.} For a first-row transition ion the spin-only formula is

μso=nu(nu+2)  B.M.,\mu_{\text{so}} = \sqrt{n_u(n_u+2)}\; \text{B.M.},

where nun_u is the number of unpaired d electrons. Putting μso=3.83\mu_{\text{so}} = 3.83 we have

3.83≈nu(nu+2).3.83 \approx \sqrt{n_u(n_u+2)}.

Trying successive integer values:

nu=2  :  2(2+2)=8=2.83 B.M. (too low)n_u=2\;:\;\sqrt{2(2+2)}=\sqrt{8}=2.83 \text{ B.M. (too low)}

nu=3  :  3(3+2)=15=3.87 B.M. (matches)n_u=3\;:\;\sqrt{3(3+2)}=\sqrt{15}=3.87 \text{ B.M. (matches)}

Therefore nu=3n_u=3. In octahedral fields high-spin d3d^3 gives three unpaired electrons, so chromium must be in the +3+3 oxidation state.

Hence z=+3z = +3 and from z=n−2z = n-2 we obtain n=3n = 3.

Summarising the deductions:

Number of coordinated chlorides x=2x = 2 (gives cis-trans isomers),

Oxidation state of Cr =+3,= +3,

Total chlorides present n=3,n = 3, of which one is outside the sphere.

The complete formula, still containing the six water molecules mentioned in the analysis, is therefore

[Cr(H2O)4Cl2]Cl⋅2H2O.[Cr(H_2O)_4Cl_2]Cl\cdot 2H_2O.

According to the IUPAC rules:

  • Ligand names are written alphabetically, ignoring numerical prefixes; therefore “aqua” (a) precedes “chlorido” (c).
  • Multiplicative prefixes (tetra, di) are used for ligands inside the bracket.
  • The oxidation state of the metal is given in Roman numerals in parentheses.
  • Counter-ions are written after the complex without any numerical prefix (“chloride”).
  • Water of crystallisation is shown at the end as “dihydrate”.

Consequently the IUPAC name is

tetraaquadichloridochromium(III) chloride dihydrate.

Tagged Structural isomerism in complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicStructural isomerism in complexes
TypeMultiple choice