RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 09 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Ionisation enthalpy

B has a smaller first ionization enthalpy than Be. Consider the following statement:
(I) it is easier to remove 2p electron than 2s electron
(II) 2p electron of B is more shielded from the nucleus by the inner core of electrons than the 2s electrons of Be
(III) 2s electron has more penetration power than 2p electron
(IV) atomic radius of B is more than Be
(atomic number B : 5, Be = 4)
The correct statements are:

SOLUTION

We first write the ground-state electronic configurations. For beryllium we have Be(Z=4):  1s2  2s2.\mathrm{Be}(Z = 4):\;1s^{2}\;2s^{2}. For boron we have B(Z=5):  1s2  2s2  2p1.\mathrm{B}(Z = 5):\;1s^{2}\;2s^{2}\;2p^{1}.

The first-ionisation enthalpy is the energy required to remove the outer-most (valence) electron from a gaseous atom. According to the general periodic trend, ionisation enthalpy increases from left to right in a period because nuclear charge increases while the principal quantum number remains the same. However, boron shows an exception: its first-ionisation enthalpy is lower than that of beryllium. To understand why, we analyse the nature of the electrons that are removed.

Be loses a 2s2s electron (2s2→2s12s^{2}\rightarrow2s^{1}), whereas B loses a 2p2p electron (2p1→2p02p^{1}\rightarrow2p^{0}). Now we discuss the four given statements one by one in the light of shielding, penetration and atomic size.

Statement (I) says “it is easier to remove a 2p2p electron than a 2s2s electron.” A 2p2p electron is farther from the nucleus on average and is shielded more effectively by the inner 1s21s^{2} and 2s22s^{2} electrons than a 2s2s electron. Hence the attraction between the nucleus and a 2p2p electron is weaker, so less energy is needed to remove it. Therefore statement (I) is true.

Statement (II) says “the 2p2p electron of B is more shielded from the nucleus by the inner core of electrons than the 2s2s electrons of Be.” Inside boron the 2p2p electron experiences the repelling effect of the already present 2s22s^{2} electrons in the same shell as well as the 1s21s^{2} core. By contrast, each 2s2s electron in beryllium is only shielded by the 1s21s^{2} core. Thus the effective nuclear charge felt by the 2p2p electron in B is lower than that felt by a 2s2s electron in Be. So the shielding of the 2p2p electron in B is indeed greater. Hence statement (II) is true.

Statement (III) says “2s2s electron has more penetration power than 2p2p electron.” Penetration refers to the probability of finding an electron close to the nucleus. For a given principal quantum number n=2n=2, the order of penetration is 2s>2p.2s > 2p. Because an ss orbital possesses a finite probability density at the nucleus whereas a pp orbital has a node there, the 2s2s electron penetrates closer to the nucleus, feels a higher effective nuclear charge, and is held more tightly. Hence statement (III) is true.

Statement (IV) says “atomic radius of B is more than Be.” Moving from Be to B across the same period, the effective nuclear charge increases (because of the extra proton) and the principal quantum number remains n=2n=2. Greater nuclear attraction pulls the electron cloud inward, so the atomic radius actually decreases. Therefore rB<rBe.r_{\text{B}} < r_{\text{Be}}. Statement (IV) is false.

Summarising, statements (I), (II) and (III) are correct, while statement (IV) is incorrect.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Ionisation enthalpy. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicIonisation enthalpy
TypeMultiple choice