RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2016 · 09 APR ONLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2016 Chemistry question — Gibbs energy and spontaneity

A reaction at 1 bar is non-spontaneous at low temperature but becomes spontaneous at high temperature. Identify the correct statement about the reaction among the following:

SOLUTION

For checking spontaneity we always examine the Gibbs free-energy change, whose expression is first stated as

ΔG  =  ΔH  −  T ΔS\Delta G \;=\; \Delta H \;-\; T\,\Delta S

where ΔG\Delta G is the Gibbs free energy change, ΔH\Delta H the enthalpy change, ΔS\Delta S the entropy change and TT the absolute temperature in kelvin.

A process is said to be spontaneous when ΔG<0\Delta G<0, non-spontaneous when ΔG>0\Delta G>0 and at equilibrium when ΔG=0\Delta G=0.

According to the question the reaction is non-spontaneous at low temperature, so for small TT we must have

ΔGlow T>0\Delta G_{\text{low }T} > 0

At high temperature the same reaction becomes spontaneous, therefore for large TT we must have

ΔGhigh T<0\Delta G_{\text{high }T} < 0

We now analyse the general expression ΔG=ΔH−TΔS\Delta G = \Delta H - T\Delta S term by term to see which signs of ΔH\Delta H and ΔS\Delta S can satisfy both of the above requirements.

Step 1: put T=0T=0 conceptually (or “very low” TT). When TT is very small, the product TΔST\Delta S will also be very small regardless of the sign of ΔS\Delta S. The value of ΔG\Delta G will then be controlled mainly by ΔH\Delta H itself:

ΔGlow T≈ΔH−(0)⋅ΔS=ΔH\Delta G_{\text{low }T} \approx \Delta H - (0)\cdot\Delta S = \Delta H

Because the reaction is non-spontaneous at low temperature, ΔGlow T\Delta G_{\text{low }T} must be positive, so

ΔH>0(enthalpy must be positive)\Delta H > 0\quad\text{(enthalpy must be positive)}

Step 2: examine T→∞T\rightarrow\infty conceptually (or “very high” TT). For a very large TT the term TΔST\Delta S dominates the expression. We have

ΔGhigh T=ΔH−TΔS\Delta G_{\text{high }T} = \Delta H - T\Delta S

Substituting the fact that ΔH>0\Delta H>0 found above gives

ΔGhigh T=(positive)−TΔS\Delta G_{\text{high }T} = (\text{positive}) - T\Delta S

To make ΔGhigh T<0\Delta G_{\text{high }T}<0 (spontaneous) the second term must outweigh the positive ΔH\Delta H, and because the minus sign stands in front, ΔS\Delta S itself must be positive so that TΔST\Delta S will be a positive quantity and its subtraction will push ΔG\Delta G into the negative region:

If  ΔS>0,ΔGhigh T=(positive)−(large positive)<0\text{If}\;\Delta S > 0,\quad \Delta G_{\text{high }T} = (\text{positive}) - (\text{large positive}) < 0

If, instead, ΔS<0\Delta S<0, then −TΔS-T\Delta S becomes positive, making ΔG\Delta G even more positive; that would never create spontaneity at high temperature and hence is ruled out.

Therefore the only consistent assignment of signs is

ΔH>0,ΔS>0\boxed{\Delta H > 0,\quad \Delta S > 0}

Let us match this conclusion with the given options:

A. ΔH\Delta H negative, ΔS\Delta S positive — rejected.

B. Both negative — rejected (gives opposite temperature dependence).

C. ΔH\Delta H positive, ΔS\Delta S negative — always non-spontaneous, rejected.

D. Both positive — exactly the condition derived above.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Gibbs energy and spontaneity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGibbs energy and spontaneity
TypeMultiple choice