A reaction at 1 bar is non-spontaneous at low temperature but becomes spontaneous at high temperature. Identify the correct statement about the reaction among the following:
For checking spontaneity we always examine the Gibbs free-energy change, whose expression is first stated as
where is the Gibbs free energy change, the enthalpy change, the entropy change and the absolute temperature in kelvin.
A process is said to be spontaneous when , non-spontaneous when and at equilibrium when .
According to the question the reaction is non-spontaneous at low temperature, so for small we must have
At high temperature the same reaction becomes spontaneous, therefore for large we must have
We now analyse the general expression term by term to see which signs of and can satisfy both of the above requirements.
Step 1: put conceptually (or “very low” ). When is very small, the product will also be very small regardless of the sign of . The value of will then be controlled mainly by itself:
Because the reaction is non-spontaneous at low temperature, must be positive, so
Step 2: examine conceptually (or “very high” ). For a very large the term dominates the expression. We have
Substituting the fact that found above gives
To make (spontaneous) the second term must outweigh the positive , and because the minus sign stands in front, itself must be positive so that will be a positive quantity and its subtraction will push into the negative region:
If, instead, , then becomes positive, making even more positive; that would never create spontaneity at high temperature and hence is ruled out.
Therefore the only consistent assignment of signs is
Let us match this conclusion with the given options:
A. negative, positive — rejected.
B. Both negative — rejected (gives opposite temperature dependence).
C. positive, negative — always non-spontaneous, rejected.
D. Both positive — exactly the condition derived above.
Hence, the correct answer is Option D.
Tagged Gibbs energy and spontaneity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.