RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2017 · 08 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2017 Chemistry question — Enthalpies of reaction and Hess's law

For a reaction, A(g)→A(l)A(g) \to A(l); ΔH=−3RT\Delta H = -3RT. The correct statement for the reaction is:

SOLUTION

We are told that one mole of a gaseous substance condenses to the liquid state:

A(g)  →  A(l)A(g)\;\rightarrow\;A(l)

and that the enthalpy change for this process is given to be

ΔH=−3RT.\Delta H = -3RT.

To compare ΔH\Delta H and ΔU\Delta U, we start from the thermodynamic relation that connects the two quantities at constant pressure. The formula (valid for reactions involving ideal gases) is

ΔH  =  ΔU  +  Δ(PV).\Delta H \;=\; \Delta U \;+\; \Delta(PV).

Because for an ideal gas PV=nRT,PV = nRT, the change in the PVPV term can be rewritten in terms of the change in the number of moles of gas, which we denote by Δng\Delta n_g:

Δ(PV)  =  Δ(nRT)  =  Δng RT.\Delta(PV) \;=\; \Delta(nRT) \;=\; \Delta n_g \, RT.

Substituting this into the first equation gives

ΔH  =  ΔU+Δng RT.\Delta H \;=\; \Delta U + \Delta n_g \, RT.

Now we identify Δng\Delta n_g for the given reaction. Initially there is 11 mole of gaseous AA, while after condensation there are 00 moles in the gas phase. Therefore,

Δng  =  nfinal (gas)  −  ninitial (gas)  =  0−1  =  −1.\Delta n_g \;=\; n_{\text{final (gas)}} \;-\; n_{\text{initial (gas)}} \;=\; 0 - 1 \;=\; -1.

Substituting Δng=−1\Delta n_g = -1 into the enthalpy-internal-energy relation we obtain

ΔH  =  ΔU+(−1) RT\Delta H \;=\; \Delta U + (-1)\,RT

or more simply

ΔH  =  ΔU−RT.\Delta H \;=\; \Delta U - RT.

But the problem statement already gives us the numerical form of ΔH\Delta H, namely ΔH=−3RT.\Delta H = -3RT. Equating the two expressions for ΔH\Delta H we have

−3RT  =  ΔU−RT.-3RT \;=\; \Delta U - RT.

Adding RTRT to both sides yields

ΔU  =  −3RT+RT  =  −2RT.\Delta U \;=\; -3RT + RT \;=\; -2RT.

Now we can compare the magnitudes of the two changes:

∣ΔH∣  =  ∣−3RT∣  =  3RT,|\Delta H| \;=\; | -3RT | \;=\; 3RT,

∣ΔU∣  =  ∣−2RT∣  =  2RT.|\Delta U| \;=\; | -2RT | \;=\; 2RT.

Clearly,

∣ΔH∣  >  ∣ΔU∣.|\Delta H| \;>\; |\Delta U|.

This inequality exactly matches Option C.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Enthalpies of reaction and Hess's law. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicEnthalpies of reaction and Hess's law
TypeMultiple choice