RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 31 AUG S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Chemistry question — Gibbs energy and spontaneity

The incorrect expression among the following is:

SOLUTION

We inspect each of the four given thermodynamic relations and compare them with the standard formulae that you would have learnt in class.

Option A states that for a reversible isothermal process of an ideal gas, the work done is

wreversible=−nRTln⁡VfVi.w_{\text{reversible}}=-nRT\ln\frac{V_f}{V_i}.

We recall the general expression for reversible work in an isothermal change of an ideal gas:

wrev=∫ViVf−P dV=∫ViVf−nRTV dV=−nRT[ln⁡V]ViVf=−nRTln⁡VfVi.w_{\text{rev}}=\int_{V_i}^{V_f} -P\,dV=\int_{V_i}^{V_f} -\frac{nRT}{V}\,dV=-nRT\left[\ln V\right]_{V_i}^{V_f}=-nRT\ln\frac{V_f}{V_i}.

The given expression matches the derivation exactly, so Option A is correct.

Option B claims

ln⁡K=ΔH∘−TΔS∘RT.\ln K=\frac{\Delta H^\circ-T\Delta S^\circ}{RT}.

To check the sign, we begin with two fundamental relationships:

1. The Gibbs-Helmholtz definition of standard free energy change: ΔG∘=ΔH∘−TΔS∘.\Delta G^\circ=\Delta H^\circ-T\Delta S^\circ.

2. The link between free energy and the equilibrium constant: ΔG∘=−RTln⁡K.\Delta G^\circ=-RT\ln K.

Now we substitute the first equation into the second:

−RTln⁡K=ΔH∘−TΔS∘.-RT\ln K=\Delta H^\circ-T\Delta S^\circ.

Multiplying both sides by −1-1 gives

RTln⁡K=−ΔH∘+TΔS∘.RT\ln K=-\Delta H^\circ+T\Delta S^\circ.

Dividing every term by RTRT yields

ln⁡K=−ΔH∘+TΔS∘RT=−ΔH∘−TΔS∘RT.\ln K=\frac{-\Delta H^\circ+T\Delta S^\circ}{RT}=-\frac{\Delta H^\circ-T\Delta S^\circ}{RT}.

Thus the correct formula contains an overall negative sign. The expression in Option B lacks this negative sign, so Option B is incorrect.

Option C gives the ratio

ΔGsystemΔStotal=−T(at constant P).\frac{\Delta G_{\text{system}}}{\Delta S_{\text{total}}}=-T\quad(\text{at constant }P).

We know the general relation for any process at constant temperature and pressure:

ΔGsystem=−TΔSuniverse=−TΔStotal.\Delta G_{\text{system}}=-T\Delta S_{\text{universe}}=-T\Delta S_{\text{total}}.

Dividing both sides by ΔStotal\Delta S_{\text{total}} immediately provides

ΔGsystemΔStotal=−T,\frac{\Delta G_{\text{system}}}{\Delta S_{\text{total}}}=-T,

exactly matching Option C. Hence Option C is correct.

Option D presents

K=e−ΔG∘/RT.K=e^{-\Delta G^\circ/RT}.

Starting once more from ΔG∘=−RTln⁡K,\Delta G^\circ=-RT\ln K, we isolate KK by exponentiation:

ln⁡K=−ΔG∘RT⟹K=e−ΔG∘/RT.\ln K=-\frac{\Delta G^\circ}{RT}\quad\Longrightarrow\quad K=e^{-\Delta G^\circ/RT}.

The option is therefore correct.

Out of the four expressions, only Option B contains an incorrect sign. All the others conform to the standard thermodynamic identities.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Gibbs energy and spontaneity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGibbs energy and spontaneity
TypeMultiple choice