Arrange the following in order of magnitude of work done by the system / on the system at constant temperature :
(a) for expansion in infinite stage.
(b) for expansion in single stage.
(c) for compression in infinite stage.
(d) for compression in single stage.
Choose the correct answer from the options given below :
For an isothermal process of an ideal gas, the work is obtained from the integral , where the sign is negative for work done by the system (expansion) and positive for work done on the system (compression). We shall compare only the magnitudes .
Step 1 : Reversible expansion or compression (infinite stages)
At every step , therefore
For an expansion, , the logarithm is positive, and for a compression, , the logarithm is negative. Taking absolute value removes the sign, so the magnitude is the same for expansion and compression:
.
Step 2 : Single-step (free) expansion
In a one-step irreversible expansion, the external pressure is suddenly lowered to the final pressure . Hence
Because during a reversible expansion the pressure continuously matches higher internal values throughout the path, . Therefore
.
Step 3 : Single-step compression
For a one-step irreversible compression the external pressure is suddenly raised to the initial internal pressure . Now
Throughout a reversible compression the gas would face lower intermediate pressures than , so . Consequently
.
Step 4 : Collecting the magnitudes
(a) , expansion ≡
(b) , expansion ≡
(c) , compression ≡
(d) , compression ≡
From Steps 1-3:
that is
Thus the correct sequence is Option B.
Tagged Heat capacity and calorimetry. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.