RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2025 · 02 APR S2+4 / −1HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2025 Chemistry question — Heat capacity and calorimetry

Arrange the following in order of magnitude of work done by the system / on the system at constant temperature :
(a) ∣wreversible∣|w_{\text{reversible}}| for expansion in infinite stage.
(b) ∣wirreversible∣|w_{\text{irreversible}}| for expansion in single stage.
(c) ∣wreversible∣|w_{\text{reversible}}| for compression in infinite stage.
(d) ∣wirreversible∣|w_{\text{irreversible}}| for compression in single stage.

Choose the correct answer from the options given below :

SOLUTION

For an isothermal process of an ideal gas, the work is obtained from the integral w=−∫Pext dVw = -\int P_{\text{ext}}\,dV, where the sign is negative for work done by the system (expansion) and positive for work done on the system (compression). We shall compare only the magnitudes ∣w∣|w|.

Step 1 : Reversible expansion or compression (infinite stages)
At every step Pext=PintP_{\text{ext}} = P_{\text{int}}, therefore
∣wreversible∣=nRT ln⁡ ⁣(V2V1)−(1)|w_{\text{reversible}}| = nRT\,\ln\!\left(\frac{V_2}{V_1}\right)\quad-(1)
For an expansion, V2>V1V_2 \gt V_1, the logarithm is positive, and for a compression, V2<V1V_2 \lt V_1, the logarithm is negative. Taking absolute value removes the sign, so the magnitude is the same for expansion and compression:
∣wrev,exp∣=∣wrev,comp∣|w_{\text{rev,exp}}| = |w_{\text{rev,comp}}|.

Step 2 : Single-step (free) expansion
In a one-step irreversible expansion, the external pressure is suddenly lowered to the final pressure P2P_2. Hence
∣wirrev,exp∣=P2 (V2−V1)−(2)|w_{\text{irrev,exp}}| = P_2\,(V_2 - V_1)\quad-(2)
Because during a reversible expansion the pressure continuously matches higher internal values throughout the path, Pavg,reversible>P2P_{\text{avg,reversible}} \gt P_2. Therefore
∣wirrev,exp∣<∣wreversible∣|w_{\text{irrev,exp}}| \lt |w_{\text{reversible}}|.

Step 3 : Single-step compression
For a one-step irreversible compression the external pressure is suddenly raised to the initial internal pressure P1P_1. Now
∣wirrev,comp∣=P1 (V1−V2)−(3)|w_{\text{irrev,comp}}| = P_1\,(V_1 - V_2)\quad-(3)
Throughout a reversible compression the gas would face lower intermediate pressures than P1P_1, so P1>Pavg,reversibleP_1 \gt P_{\text{avg,reversible}}. Consequently
∣wirrev,comp∣>∣wreversible∣|w_{\text{irrev,comp}}| \gt |w_{\text{reversible}}|.

Step 4 : Collecting the magnitudes
(a) ∣wreversible∣|w_{\text{reversible}}|, expansion  ≡  ∣wrev,exp∣|w_{\text{rev,exp}}|
(b) ∣wirreversible∣|w_{\text{irreversible}}|, expansion  ≡  ∣wirrev,exp∣|w_{\text{irrev,exp}}|
(c) ∣wreversible∣|w_{\text{reversible}}|, compression  ≡  ∣wrev,comp∣|w_{\text{rev,comp}}|
(d) ∣wirreversible∣|w_{\text{irreversible}}|, compression  ≡  ∣wirrev,comp∣|w_{\text{irrev,comp}}|

From Steps 1-3:
∣wirrev,comp∣>∣wrev,comp∣=∣wrev,exp∣>∣wirrev,exp∣,|w_{\text{irrev,comp}}| \gt |w_{\text{rev,comp}}| = |w_{\text{rev,exp}}| \gt |w_{\text{irrev,exp}}|,
that is
d>c=a>b.d \gt c = a \gt b.

Thus the correct sequence is Option B.

Tagged Heat capacity and calorimetry. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicHeat capacity and calorimetry
TypeMultiple choice