RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2006TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2006 Chemistry question — First law: work, heat and internal energy

An ideal gas is allowed to expand both reversibly and irreversibly in an isolated system. If TiT_i is the initial temperature and TfT_f is the final temperature, which of the following statements is correct?

SOLUTION

An isolated system exchanges neither heat nor matter with the surroundings, therefore for every process occurring in it

q=0    ⟹    ΔU=q+w=w  −(1)q = 0 \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; \Delta U = q + w = w \;-(1)

For an ideal gas the internal energy depends only on temperature:

ΔU=nCv (Tf−Ti)  −(2)\Delta U = nC_v\,(T_f - T_i) \;-(2)

Combining (1)(1) and (2)(2) gives

nCv (Tf−Ti)=wnC_v\,(T_f - T_i) = w ⟹    Tf=Ti+wnCv  −(3)\Longrightarrow\;\; T_f = T_i + \dfrac{w}{nC_v} \;-(3)

Next, compare the work terms for expansion:

• Sign convention used in chemical thermodynamics: ww is positive when work is done on the system, negative when work is done by the system.
• During any expansion the system does work on the surroundings, so w<0w \lt 0.

Maximum (most negative) work is obtained in a reversible expansion, while any irreversible expansion does less (is numerically less negative) work:

wrev<wirrev  −(4)w_{\text{rev}} \lt w_{\text{irrev}} \;-(4)

Substitute (4)(4) into (3)(3):

Tf,rev=Ti+wrevnCvT_{f,\text{rev}} = T_i + \dfrac{w_{\text{rev}}}{nC_v} Tf,irrev=Ti+wirrevnCvT_{f,\text{irrev}} = T_i + \dfrac{w_{\text{irrev}}}{nC_v}

Because the denominators are the same and wrev<wirrevw_{\text{rev}} \lt w_{\text{irrev}}, the increment in temperature is more negative for the reversible path. Hence

(Tf)irrev>(Tf)rev(T_f)_{\text{irrev}} \gt (T_f)_{\text{rev}}

Therefore, in an isolated ideal-gas expansion the irreversible process ends at a higher final temperature than the reversible process.

Option A which is: (Tf)irrev  >  (Tf)rev(T_f)_{irrev} \;>\; (T_f)_{rev}

Tagged First law: work, heat and internal energy. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicFirst law: work, heat and internal energy
TypeMultiple choice