RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 16 APR ONLINE+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Chemistry question — Gibbs energy and spontaneity

For which of the following processes, ΔS\Delta S is negative?

SOLUTION

First, let us recall the basic thermodynamic idea of entropy. Entropy (SS) is a quantitative measure of disorder or randomness. Whenever the randomness of a system increases, ΔS=Sfinal−Sinitial\Delta S = S_{\text{final}}-S_{\text{initial}} becomes positive, and whenever the randomness decreases, ΔS\Delta S becomes negative.

We now examine each of the four given processes one by one, always asking, “Does the disorder go up or down?”

Process A : C (diamond)→C (graphite)\text{C (diamond)} \rightarrow \text{C (graphite)}

Diamond has a rigid three-dimensional covalent lattice, while graphite consists of planar sheets that can slide over one another. The atomic arrangement in graphite is therefore much less ordered than in diamond, i.e., more random. So

ΔSA>0\Delta S_{\text{A}} > 0

Hence ΔS\Delta S is positive, not negative.

Process B : N2\text{N}_2(g, 1 atm) →\rightarrow N2\text{N}_2(g, 5 atm)

This is an isothermal compression of an ideal gas from an initial pressure P1=1  atmP_1 = 1\;\text{atm} to a final pressure P2=5  atmP_2 = 5\;\text{atm}. At constant temperature, the entropy change of an ideal gas can be written in two equivalent ways:

ΔS=nRln⁡ ⁣(V2V1)orΔS=− nRln⁡ ⁣(P2P1)\boxed{\displaystyle \Delta S = nR\ln\!\left(\frac{V_2}{V_1}\right)} \qquad\text{or}\qquad \boxed{\displaystyle \Delta S = -\,nR\ln\!\left(\frac{P_2}{P_1}\right)}

We use the second form because pressures are given. Substituting P1=1  atmP_1 = 1\;\text{atm} and P2=5  atmP_2 = 5\;\text{atm}, we obtain

ΔSB=− nRln⁡ ⁣(P2P1)=− nRln⁡ ⁣(51)=− nRln⁡5\Delta S_{\text{B}} = -\,nR\ln\!\left(\frac{P_2}{P_1}\right) = -\,nR\ln\!\left(\frac{5}{1}\right) = -\,nR\ln 5

Since ln⁡5\ln 5 is positive, the entire right-hand side is negative:

ΔSB<0\Delta S_{\text{B}} < 0

Thus, the entropy decreases during this compression; we have a negative ΔS\Delta S here.

Process C : N2\text{N}_2(g, 273 K) →\rightarrow N2\text{N}_2(g, 300 K) (pressure unchanged)

Heating a gas at constant pressure increases the average molecular speed and the number of accessible microstates. Therefore randomness rises:

ΔSC>0\Delta S_{\text{C}} > 0

Process D : H2(g)→2H(g)\text{H}_2(g) \rightarrow 2\text{H}(g)

One diatomic molecule breaks into two monatomic species, doubling the number of independent particles. The positional and translational disorder increases markedly, giving

ΔSD>0\Delta S_{\text{D}} > 0

Out of the four situations, only Process B shows a decrease in entropy. Hence, the process for which ΔS\Delta S is negative corresponds to Option B.

Hence, the correct answer is Option 2.

Tagged Gibbs energy and spontaneity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGibbs energy and spontaneity
TypeMultiple choice