RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 11 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Gibbs energy and spontaneity

For the chemical reaction X⇌YX \rightleftharpoons Y, the standard reaction Gibbs energy depends on temperature T (in K) as ΔrG°\Delta_r G° (in kJ mol−1^{-1}) =120−38T= 120 - \frac{3}{8}T. The major component of the reaction mixture at T is:

SOLUTION

We start with the given temperature-dependence of the standard reaction Gibbs energy for the equilibrium

X  ⇌  YX \; \rightleftharpoons \; Y

The expression supplied in the question is

ΔrG∘  (kJ mol−1)  =  120  −  38 T\Delta_r G^{\circ} \; (\text{kJ mol}^{-1}) \;=\; 120 \;-\; \dfrac{3}{8}\,T

where TT is the temperature in kelvin.

To decide which species is the major component at a particular temperature, we recall the fundamental thermodynamic relation

ΔrG∘  =  − R T ln⁡K\Delta_r G^{\circ} \;=\; -\,R\,T \,\ln K

Here RR is the universal gas constant and KK is the equilibrium constant for the reaction X⇌YX \rightleftharpoons Y.

When ΔrG∘<0\Delta_r G^{\circ}<0, the right-hand side (product Y) is favoured, so K>1K>1 and Y becomes the predominant species. Conversely, when ΔrG∘>0\Delta_r G^{\circ}>0, the left-hand side (reactant X) is favoured, so K<1K<1 and X predominates.

We now evaluate ΔrG∘\Delta_r G^{\circ} at each temperature mentioned in the options.

First we substitute T=300  KT = 300\;\text{K}:

ΔrG∘  =  120  −  38×300  =  120  −  112.5  =  7.5  kJ mol−1\Delta_r G^{\circ} \;=\; 120 \;-\; \dfrac{3}{8}\times 300 \;=\; 120 \;-\; 112.5 \;=\; 7.5 \;\text{kJ mol}^{-1}

The value is positive, so X is favoured, not Y. Hence Option A is incorrect.

Next we substitute T=280  KT = 280\;\text{K}:

ΔrG∘  =  120  −  38×280  =  120  −  105  =  15  kJ mol−1\Delta_r G^{\circ} \;=\; 120 \;-\; \dfrac{3}{8}\times 280 \;=\; 120 \;-\; 105 \;=\; 15 \;\text{kJ mol}^{-1}

This is again positive, meaning X is favoured, not Y. Thus Option B is incorrect.

Now we substitute T=350  KT = 350\;\text{K}:

ΔrG∘  =  120  −  38×350  =  120  −  131.25  =  −11.25  kJ mol−1\Delta_r G^{\circ} \;=\; 120 \;-\; \dfrac{3}{8}\times 350 \;=\; 120 \;-\; 131.25 \;=\; -11.25 \;\text{kJ mol}^{-1}

The value is negative, so Y is favoured, not X. Therefore Option C is incorrect.

Finally we substitute T=315  KT = 315\;\text{K}:

ΔrG∘  =  120  −  38×315  =  120  −  118.125  =  1.875  kJ mol−1\Delta_r G^{\circ} \;=\; 120 \;-\; \dfrac{3}{8}\times 315 \;=\; 120 \;-\; 118.125 \;=\; 1.875 \;\text{kJ mol}^{-1}

This is a positive number, implying K<1K<1, so the reactant X is present in greater amount than Y. Hence X is the major component at 315 K.

Among the four choices, only Option D matches this conclusion.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Gibbs energy and spontaneity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGibbs energy and spontaneity
TypeMultiple choice