RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 10 APR S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Gibbs energy and spontaneity

A process will be spontaneous at all temperatures if:

SOLUTION

We recall the basic thermodynamic criterion for spontaneity, namely the Gibbs free-energy change. The relation is stated as

ΔG  =  ΔH  −  T ΔS\Delta G \;=\; \Delta H \;-\; T\,\Delta S

where ΔG\Delta G is the change in Gibbs free energy, ΔH\Delta H is the enthalpy change, TT is the absolute temperature and ΔS\Delta S is the entropy change. A process is spontaneous when

ΔG  <  0.\Delta G \; < \; 0.

Substituting the expression for ΔG\Delta G, the condition for spontaneity becomes

ΔH−T ΔS  <  0.\Delta H - T\,\Delta S \; < \; 0.

Now we must find which combination of signs for ΔH\Delta H and ΔS\Delta S guarantees that the left-hand side remains negative for every value of the temperature T>0T > 0.

We consider each possible sign combination one by one, always remembering that TT is positive:

1. Suppose ΔH<0\Delta H < 0 and ΔS<0\Delta S < 0. Then the term ΔH\Delta H is negative, but the term −T ΔS-T\,\Delta S becomes positive because ΔS\Delta S is negative and the minus sign in front of TΔST\Delta S changes it. At low temperatures the negative enthalpy might dominate and make ΔG\Delta G negative, but as TT increases the positive contribution −TΔS-T\Delta S grows and can eventually outweigh ΔH\Delta H. Hence spontaneity would not persist at all temperatures.

2. Now take ΔH<0\Delta H < 0 and ΔS>0\Delta S > 0. Here ΔH\Delta H is negative and the term −T ΔS-T\,\Delta S is also negative because ΔS\Delta S is positive and there is already a minus sign. Therefore both contributions are negative for every positive TT, giving

ΔG  =  (negative)+(negative)  =  negative for all T.\Delta G \;=\; \text{(negative)} + \text{(negative)} \;=\; \text{negative for all } T.

So the inequality ΔG<0\Delta G < 0 is satisfied at every temperature.

3. Consider ΔH>0\Delta H > 0 and ΔS>0\Delta S > 0. The enthalpy term is positive, while the entropy term −T ΔS-T\,\Delta S is negative. At low temperatures the positive enthalpy dominates, making ΔG\Delta G positive, so the reaction will not be spontaneous there. Thus this pair of signs does not guarantee spontaneity at all temperatures.

4. Finally, if ΔH>0\Delta H > 0 and ΔS<0\Delta S < 0, both ΔH\Delta H and −T ΔS-T\,\Delta S are positive, yielding ΔG>0\Delta G > 0 for every TT. Such a process is never spontaneous.

Only the second combination, ΔH<0\Delta H < 0 along with ΔS>0\Delta S > 0, makes the Gibbs free-energy change negative irrespective of the temperature.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Gibbs energy and spontaneity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGibbs energy and spontaneity
TypeMultiple choice