A process will be spontaneous at all temperatures if:
We recall the basic thermodynamic criterion for spontaneity, namely the Gibbs free-energy change. The relation is stated as
where is the change in Gibbs free energy, is the enthalpy change, is the absolute temperature and is the entropy change. A process is spontaneous when
Substituting the expression for , the condition for spontaneity becomes
Now we must find which combination of signs for and guarantees that the left-hand side remains negative for every value of the temperature .
We consider each possible sign combination one by one, always remembering that is positive:
1. Suppose and . Then the term is negative, but the term becomes positive because is negative and the minus sign in front of changes it. At low temperatures the negative enthalpy might dominate and make negative, but as increases the positive contribution grows and can eventually outweigh . Hence spontaneity would not persist at all temperatures.
2. Now take and . Here is negative and the term is also negative because is positive and there is already a minus sign. Therefore both contributions are negative for every positive , giving
So the inequality is satisfied at every temperature.
3. Consider and . The enthalpy term is positive, while the entropy term is negative. At low temperatures the positive enthalpy dominates, making positive, so the reaction will not be spontaneous there. Thus this pair of signs does not guarantee spontaneity at all temperatures.
4. Finally, if and , both and are positive, yielding for every . Such a process is never spontaneous.
Only the second combination, along with , makes the Gibbs free-energy change negative irrespective of the temperature.
Hence, the correct answer is Option B.
Tagged Gibbs energy and spontaneity. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.