RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 09 APR S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Chemistry question — Nucleophilic addition reactions of carbonyl compounds

In the following reaction:
carbonyl compound + MeOH ⇌HCl\overset{\mathrm{HCl}}{\rightleftharpoons} acetal
Rate of the reaction is the highest for:

SOLUTION

We are dealing with the acid-catalysed conversion of a carbonyl compound to an acetal in methanol. The simplified mechanism proceeds through these key elementary steps:

(1) Protonation of the carbonyl: R2C=O+H+⟶R2C=OH+\text{(1) Protonation of the carbonyl: }R_{2}C=O + H^+ \longrightarrow R_{2}C=OH^+

(2) Nucleophilic attack by methanol: R2C=OH++MeOH⟶R2C(OMe)OH+H+\text{(2) Nucleophilic attack by methanol: }R_{2}C=OH^+ + MeOH \longrightarrow R_{2}C(OMe)OH + H^+

The overall rate, to a very good approximation in the initial stages, is proportional to the concentrations of the species actually colliding in the slow step. After the fast proton-transfer of step (1), the slow or rate-determining step is generally step (2). Therefore we can write

Rate∝[protonated carbonyl] [MeOH].\text{Rate} \propto [\text{protonated carbonyl}]\,[\text{MeOH}].

Now we compare the options on the basis of two independent factors that control this rate expression:

Factor 1: Nature of the carbonyl electrophile.

An aldehyde is more electrophilic than a ketone because:

(i) it has only one electron-donating alkyl group instead of two, so the carbonyl carbon bears a larger partial positive charge, and

(ii) it suffers less steric hindrance to nucleophilic attack.

Hence Ratealdehyde>Rateketone.\text{Rate}_{\text{aldehyde}} > \text{Rate}_{\text{ketone}}.

Between the substrates listed, propanal (an aldehyde) is thus inherently faster than acetone (a ketone).

Factor 2: Concentration of the nucleophile MeOH.

The rate expression contains [MeOH],[\text{MeOH}], so increasing the concentration of methanol directly raises the rate. Using methanol in excess means a higher [MeOH][\text{MeOH}] than in a stoichiometric amount.

Therefore Rateexcess MeOH>Ratestoichiometric MeOH.\text{Rate}_{\text{excess MeOH}} > \text{Rate}_{\text{stoichiometric MeOH}}.

Let us rank the four options by systematically combining these two factors.

Step 1 - Substrate effect:

Propanal options (B and C) > Acetone options (A and D).

Step 2 - Methanol concentration effect (within each substrate type):

Excess MeOH (B and D) > Stoichiometric MeOH (A and C).

Combining both steps:

The single option that has the more reactive aldehyde and methanol in excess is Option B.

Mathematically, if we denote the proportionality constant as kk and use subscripts to distinguish situations, we can write

RateB=k[propanal ⁣− ⁣H+][MeOH]excess,\text{Rate}_{\text{B}} = k[\text{propanal}\!-\!\text{H}^+][\text{MeOH}]_{\text{excess}},

RateC=k[propanal ⁣− ⁣H+][MeOH]stoich,\text{Rate}_{\text{C}} = k[\text{propanal}\!-\!\text{H}^+][\text{MeOH}]_{\text{stoich}},

and clearly [MeOH]excess>[MeOH]stoich,[\text{MeOH}]_{\text{excess}} > [\text{MeOH}]_{\text{stoich}}, so RateB>RateC.\text{Rate}_{\text{B}} > \text{Rate}_{\text{C}}.

Any rate involving acetone will already be slower due to the less electrophilic carbonyl, cementing the conclusion that

RateB>RateD>RateC>RateA.\text{Rate}_{\text{B}} > \text{Rate}_{\text{D}} \gt \text{Rate}_{\text{C}} \gt \text{Rate}_{\text{A}}.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Nucleophilic addition reactions of carbonyl compounds. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicNucleophilic addition reactions of carbonyl compounds
TypeMultiple choice