RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2017 · 09 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2017 Chemistry question — Nucleophilic addition reactions of carbonyl compounds

A compound of molecular formula C8_8H8_8O2_2 reacts with acetophenone to form a single cross-aldol product in the presence of base. The same compound on reaction with concentrated NaOH forms benzyl alcohol as one of the products. The structure of the compound is:

SOLUTION

We are told that the unknown organic compound has the molecular formula C8H8O2C_8H_8O_2. We also know two important pieces of reactivity:

(i) It reacts with acetophenone (C6H5COCH3)\left(C_6H_5COCH_3\right) in the presence of base to give a single cross-aldol (more precisely, Claisen-Schmidt) condensation product.

(ii) When treated with concentrated NaOHNaOH it produces benzyl alcohol (C6H5CH2OH)\left(C_6H_5CH_2OH\right) among the products.

Let us analyse each clue step by step and compare with the four given structures.

Step 1 Checking the molecular formula of every option

First we write the molecular formula for every candidate compound, counting all carbon, hydrogen and oxygen atoms.

A. Methoxybenzaldehyde (p-CH3O ⁣− ⁣C6H4 ⁣− ⁣CHOCH_3O\!-\!C_6H_4\!-\!CHO) Ring C6H4C_6H_4 gives C6H4C_6H_4     Side groups: CH3OCH_3O contributes C1H3O1C_1H_3O_1, and CHOCHO contributes C1H1O1C_1H_1O_1.     Total: C6+1+1=C8,  H4+3+1=H8,  O1+1=O2.C_{6+1+1}=C_8,\;H_{4+3+1}=H_8,\;O_{1+1}=O_2.     So option A exactly matches C8H8O2.C_8H_8O_2.

B. Methyl benzoate (C6H5COOCH3)\left(C_6H_5COOCH_3\right)     Ring C6H5C_6H_5 plus COOCH3COOCH_3 (which is C2H3O2C_2H_3O_2).     Total: C6+2=C8,  H5+3=H8,  O2.C_{6+2}=C_8,\;H_{5+3}=H_8,\;O_2.     This also fits C8H8O2.C_8H_8O_2.

C. p-Methylbenzoic acid (p-CH3 ⁣− ⁣C6H4 ⁣− ⁣COOHCH_3\!-\!C_6H_4\!-\!COOH)     Ring C6H4C_6H_4, plus CH3CH_3 ( C1H3C_1H_3 ), plus COOHCOOH ( C1H1O2C_1H_1O_2 ).     Total: C6+1+1=C8,  H4+3+1=H8,  O2.C_{6+1+1}=C_8,\;H_{4+3+1}=H_8,\;O_2.     Again it fits the formula.

D. p-Hydroxy methyl acetophenone (HO-C6H4 ⁣− ⁣COCH3C_6H_4\!-\!COCH_3)     Ring C6H4C_6H_4, plus OHOH ( O1H1O_1H_1 ), plus COCH3COCH_3 ( C2H3O1C_2H_3O_1 ).     Total: C6+2=C8,  H4+1+3=H8,  O1+1=O2.C_{6+2}=C_8,\;H_{4+1+3}=H_8,\;O_{1+1}=O_2.     This also matches C8H8O2.C_8H_8O_2.

Thus the molecular formula alone keeps all four options in the race, so we must rely on the given reactions.

Step 2 Interpreting the reaction with acetophenone under basic conditions

The phrase “reacts with acetophenone to form a single cross-aldol product in the presence of base” is the textual description of a Claisen-Schmidt condensation. The general fact we must recall is:

In an aldol/Claisen-Schmidt reaction, the likelihood of getting a single product is highest when one carbonyl component has no α-hydrogens. Such a carbonyl compound can act only as an electrophile (acceptor) and never as an enolate donor.

Among ordinary carbonyl groups, an aromatic aldehyde Ar−CHOAr-CHO possesses no hydrogens at the α-position because the carbonyl carbon is directly attached to the aromatic ring, not to a carbon bearing hydrogens. Hence compounds of the type Ar−CHOAr-CHO satisfy the “no α-H” condition and always give a single cross-aldol product with a ketone such as acetophenone.

We now examine which options contain an aldehyde group and lack α-hydrogens.

A. Methoxybenzaldehyde - contains   CHO\;CHO attached to an aromatic ring. No α-H present.

B. Methyl benzoate - is an ester. Esters do not undergo the ordinary aldol mechanism with acetophenone.

C. p-Methylbenzoic acid - is a carboxylic acid, not an aldehyde, and therefore not eligible for aldol condensation.

D. p-Hydroxy methyl acetophenone - is a ketone with a CH3CH_3 group next to the carbonyl; it does have α-hydrogens, so multiple self- and cross-aldol products would be possible. This contradicts the “single product” statement.

Therefore, only option A is consistent with the first observation.

Step 3 Interpreting the reaction with concentrated NaOH giving benzyl alcohol

Now we recall another well-known reaction:

The Cannizzaro reaction states that an aldehyde devoid of α-hydrogens, when treated with strong base (concentrated NaOHNaOH), undergoes self-redox to give one molecule reduced to an alcohol and another oxidised to a carboxylate salt.

Symbolically, for an aldehyde Ar−CHOAr-CHO with no α-H,

2 Ar−CHO  →    conc.  NaOH  Ar−CH2OH  +  Ar−COO−Na+2\,Ar-CHO \;\xrightarrow[\;]{\;conc.\;NaOH\;} Ar-CH_2OH \;+\; Ar-COO^-Na^+

One of the products is always the corresponding benzyl alcohol Ar−CH2OHAr-CH_2OH. This is exactly the second clue in the question.

Which of the options can undergo a Cannizzaro reaction?

A. Methoxybenzaldehyde - yes, it is an aldehyde lacking α-H; Cannizzaro feasible.

B. Methyl benzoate - ester; Cannizzaro not possible.

C. p-Methylbenzoic acid - carboxylic acid; Cannizzaro not possible.

D. p-Hydroxy methyl acetophenone - a ketone with α-H; Cannizzaro does not occur.

Again, only option A satisfies the second observation.

Step 4 Final decision

Both experimental facts - exclusive cross-aldol product formation with acetophenone and the Cannizzaro reaction giving benzyl alcohol - point unambiguously to an aromatic aldehyde that lacks α-hydrogens. Among the given choices, that description fits only p-methoxybenzaldehyde.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Nucleophilic addition reactions of carbonyl compounds. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicNucleophilic addition reactions of carbonyl compounds
TypeMultiple choice