RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2023 · 30 JAN S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2023 Chemistry question — Distinguishing tests for aldehydes and ketones

Which of the following compounds would give the following set of qualitative analysis?
(i) Fehling's Test: Positive
(ii) Na fusion extract upon treatment with sodium nitroprusside gives a blood red colour but not prussian blue.

SOLUTION
  1. Fehling's Test (Positive):

    A positive Fehling's test indicates the presence of an aliphatic aldehyde group (–CHO\text{--CHO}). This eliminates any option that contains a ketone, ester, or other non-reducing functional groups, focusing our attention on compounds with an active formyl functionality.


  2. Sodium Fusion Extract (Lassaigne's Test) with Sodium Nitroprusside:

    When an organic compound containing both Nitrogen (N\text{N}) and Sulfur (S\text{S}) is fused with sodium metal, they react together with carbon to form sodium thiocyanate (NaSCN\text{NaSCN}):

    Na+C+N+S→NaSCN\text{Na} + \text{C} + \text{N} + \text{S} \rightarrow \text{NaSCN}
    • Blood-Red Coloration: When ferric ions (Fe3+\text{Fe}^{3+}) or specific complexing reagents like sodium nitroprusside are introduced into an acidified thiocyanate extract solution, it yields a characteristic blood-red color due to the formation of ferric thiocyanate complexes:
    • Fe3++SCN⊖→[Fe(SCN)]2+(Blood-Red Solution)\text{Fe}^{3+} + \text{SCN}^\ominus \rightarrow [\text{Fe}(\text{SCN})]^{2+} \quad \text{(Blood-Red Solution)}
    • Absence of Prussian Blue: Because both nitrogen and sulfur are fixed together as thiocyanate (SCN⊖\text{SCN}^\ominus) rather than isolated cyanide (CN⊖\text{CN}^\ominus) ions, there are no free cyanide ions available to form the classic Prussian blue complex (Fe4[Fe(CN)6]3\text{Fe}_4[\text{Fe}(\text{CN})_6]_3).

    Therefore, the compound must contain both nitrogen and sulfur atoms alongside its aldehyde group.


Evaluating the Structural Candidates:

  • Oxazole derivatives: Contain Nitrogen (N\text{N}) and Oxygen (O\text{O}), but lack Sulfur (S\text{S}). They do not give a blood-red color during Lassaigne's element detection.
  • Pyrrole derivatives: Contain Nitrogen (N\text{N}), but lack Sulfur (S\text{S}), giving a Prussian blue test rather than blood-red thiocyanate formations.
  • 2-Thiazolecarboxaldehyde (C4H3NOS\text{C}_4\text{H}_3\text{NOS}): The thiazole ring features both an aromatic nitrogen atom and a sulfur heteroatom in its cyclic core, along with a directly attached formyl group (–CHO\text{--CHO}). This perfectly satisfies both the structural and chemical criteria.

Conclusion:

The simultaneous presence of the aldehyde moiety and both nitrogen and sulfur within the thiazole ring framework satisfies all requirements for a positive Fehling's reaction and a blood-red Lassaigne's outcome.

Answer: Option C (2-Thiazolecarboxaldehyde)

Tagged Distinguishing tests for aldehydes and ketones. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicDistinguishing tests for aldehydes and ketones
TypeMultiple choice