Key idea: Clemmensen reduction (Zn–Hg/conc. HCl) reduces aldehyde and ketone carbonyls to CHX2/CHX3. The C=O of an ester is not reduced.
- The substrate has three carbonyl groups on the ring: an acetyl (−COCHX3), a formyl (−CHO) and an ethyl ester (−COOCX2HX5).
- Ketone: −COCHX3Zn−Hg/HCl−CHX2CHX3 (ethyl group)
- Aldehyde: −CHOZn−Hg/HCl−CHX3 (methyl group)
- Ester: unchanged. Clemmensen conditions do not reduce ester carbonyls, and nothing reduces them to alcohols here.
- P = ethyl 3-ethyl-5-methylbenzoate, which is (A).
(B), (C) and (D) contain −CHX2OH groups, which would need a hydride reagent such as LiAlHX4/NaBHX4.
Answer: (A)