Which of the following arrangements with respect to their reactivity in nucleophilic addition reaction is correct?
Nucleophilic addition to a carbonyl group occurs at the electrophilic carbon of the bond. The rate depends on two main factors:
• Electronic effects: groups that withdraw electrons ( and/or ) increase the partial positive charge on the carbonyl carbon and enhance reactivity. Groups that donate electrons ( and/or ) decrease the charge and slow the reaction.
• Steric effects: less‐hindered carbonyls are more accessible to the nucleophile.
First compare aldehydes and ketones attached to an aromatic ring.
• Aldehydes have only one alkyl/aryl group attached to the carbonyl carbon, so they are less sterically hindered and receive less donation than ketones. Hence aromatic aldehydes are more reactive than aromatic ketones.
• Therefore is expected to be the least reactive of the four compounds.
Now compare the three aromatic aldehydes:
1. contains a group. is strongly electron-withdrawing by both (inductive) and (resonance) effects, so it makes the carbonyl carbon highly electrophilic. This gives the HIGHEST reactivity.
2. has no extra substituent on the ring, so its reactivity is taken as the reference among aldehydes.
3. (para-methylbenzaldehyde) contains a group. is electron-donating by and weakly , so it reduces the electrophilicity of the carbonyl carbon, lowering the reactivity below that of unsubstituted benzaldehyde.
Putting the steric and electronic arguments together:
This sequence matches Option D.
Answer: Option D
Tagged Nucleophilic addition reactions of carbonyl compounds. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.