RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 02 SEP S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Chemistry question — Nucleophilic addition reactions of carbonyl compounds

Two compounds A and B with same molecular formula (C3H6O)(C_3H_6O) undergo Grignard reaction with methylmagnesium bromide to give products C and D. Products C and D show following chemical tests:

TestCD
Ceric ammonium nitrate TestPositivePositive
Lucas TestTurbidity obtained after five minutesTurbidity obtained Immediately
Iodoform TestPositiveNegative


C and D respectively are:

SOLUTION

We begin by noting that both compounds A and B have the molecular formula C3H6OC_3H_6O. Such a formula fits carbonyl compounds having three carbon atoms, namely

propanal : CH3CH2CHO(an aldehyde)\text{propanal : }CH_3CH_2CHO\quad\text{(an aldehyde)}

acetone : CH3COCH3(a ketone)\text{acetone : }CH_3COCH_3\quad\text{(a ketone)}

When a carbonyl compound is treated with a Grignard reagent, an alkyl group is added to the carbonyl carbon and the oxygen is converted into an alcohol after acidic work-up. Stating the general result first,

R-C(=O)-R’+CH3MgBr→H3O+R-C(OH)(CH3)-R’\text{R-C(=O)-R'} + CH_3MgBr \overset{H_3O^+}{\rightarrow} \text{R-C(OH)(CH}_3\text{)-R'}

So each carbonyl compound of three carbons will give an alcohol of four carbons, because one extra CH3CH_3 group is introduced.

1. Reaction of propanal with CH3MgBrCH_3MgBr

Starting carbonyl:

CH3CH2CHOCH_3CH_2CHO

Addition of CH3−CH_3^- from the Grignard reagent at the carbonyl carbon followed by protonation gives

CH3CH2C(OH)(CH3)H  =  CH3CH2CH(OH)CH3CH_3CH_2C(OH)(CH_3)H \;=\;CH_3CH_2CH(OH)CH_3

This product is butan-2-ol, a secondary alcohol. Let us call it product C.

2. Reaction of acetone with CH3MgBrCH_3MgBr

Starting carbonyl:

CH3COCH3CH_3COCH_3

Addition of CH3−CH_3^- and protonation gives

CH3C(OH)(CH3)CH3  =  (CH3)3C OHCH_3C(OH)(CH_3)CH_3 \;=\;(CH_3)_3C\,OH

This product is 2-methyl-2-propanol (tert-butyl alcohol), a tertiary alcohol. Let us call it product D.

Now we match C and D with the chemical tests given.

(i) Ceric ammonium nitrate test - any alcohol answers it, so both C and D should be positive, exactly as observed.

(ii) Lucas test - the rate of turbidity distinguishes the class of alcohol.

• Secondary alcohols turn turbid in about five minutes.
• Tertiary alcohols turn turbid immediately.

Product C is a secondary alcohol (butan-2-ol) →\rightarrow turbidity after five minutes.
Product D is a tertiary alcohol (tert-butyl alcohol) →\rightarrow instantaneous turbidity.

(iii) Iodoform test - positive for ethanol or any secondary alcohol that contains the fragment CH3−CH(OH)−CH_3-CH(OH)-.

• Butan-2-ol possesses the CH3−CH(OH)−CH_3-CH(OH)- group, so C gives a positive iodoform test.
• tert-Butyl alcohol lacks that fragment, so D gives a negative iodoform test.

The behaviour predicted for butan-2-ol and tert-butyl alcohol coincides perfectly with the observations. Therefore

C=CH3CH2CH(OH)CH3(butan-2-ol)C = CH_3CH_2CH(OH)CH_3\quad(\text{butan-2-ol})

D=(CH3)3C OH(tert-butyl alcohol)D = (CH_3)_3C\,OH\quad(\text{tert-butyl alcohol})

Looking at the options, these structures are listed together only in Option A:

C=H3C−CH2−CH(OH)−CH3;  D=H3C−C(CH3)2−OHC = H_3C-CH_2-CH(OH)-CH_3;\; D = H_3C-C(CH_3)_2-OH

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Nucleophilic addition reactions of carbonyl compounds. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicNucleophilic addition reactions of carbonyl compounds
TypeMultiple choice