Two compounds A and B with same molecular formula undergo Grignard reaction with methylmagnesium bromide to give products C and D. Products C and D show following chemical tests:
| Test | C | D |
|---|---|---|
| Ceric ammonium nitrate Test | Positive | Positive |
| Lucas Test | Turbidity obtained after five minutes | Turbidity obtained Immediately |
| Iodoform Test | Positive | Negative |
C and D respectively are:
We begin by noting that both compounds A and B have the molecular formula . Such a formula fits carbonyl compounds having three carbon atoms, namely
When a carbonyl compound is treated with a Grignard reagent, an alkyl group is added to the carbonyl carbon and the oxygen is converted into an alcohol after acidic work-up. Stating the general result first,
So each carbonyl compound of three carbons will give an alcohol of four carbons, because one extra group is introduced.
1. Reaction of propanal with
Starting carbonyl:
Addition of from the Grignard reagent at the carbonyl carbon followed by protonation gives
This product is butan-2-ol, a secondary alcohol. Let us call it product C.
2. Reaction of acetone with
Starting carbonyl:
Addition of and protonation gives
This product is 2-methyl-2-propanol (tert-butyl alcohol), a tertiary alcohol. Let us call it product D.
Now we match C and D with the chemical tests given.
(i) Ceric ammonium nitrate test - any alcohol answers it, so both C and D should be positive, exactly as observed.
(ii) Lucas test - the rate of turbidity distinguishes the class of alcohol.
• Secondary alcohols turn turbid in about five minutes.
• Tertiary alcohols turn turbid immediately.
Product C is a secondary alcohol (butan-2-ol) turbidity after five minutes.
Product D is a tertiary alcohol (tert-butyl alcohol) instantaneous turbidity.
(iii) Iodoform test - positive for ethanol or any secondary alcohol that contains the fragment .
• Butan-2-ol possesses the group, so C gives a positive iodoform test.
• tert-Butyl alcohol lacks that fragment, so D gives a negative iodoform test.
The behaviour predicted for butan-2-ol and tert-butyl alcohol coincides perfectly with the observations. Therefore
Looking at the options, these structures are listed together only in Option A:
Hence, the correct answer is Option A.
Tagged Nucleophilic addition reactions of carbonyl compounds. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.