- –CO2Et (Ester)→–CH2OH (Primary Alcohol) : Reduced
- –CO2H (Carboxylic Acid)→–CO2H (Carboxylic Acid) : Protected / Unchanged
- –CN (Nitrile)→–CHO (Aldehyde) : Reduced selectively to an aldehyde
Detailed Evaluation of Each Option:
-
Option A: (i) NaBH4, (ii) Raney Ni/H2, (iii) H3O+
- NaBH4 is a mild reducing agent that generally does not reduce esters, carboxylic acids, or nitriles under standard conditions. Thus, step (i) will fail to convert the ester to an alcohol.
- Raney Ni/H2 reduces nitrile (−CN) groups completely down to primary amines (−CH2NH2), not aldehydes (−CHO).
- Result: Incorrect transformation products.
-
Option B: (i) LiAlH4, (ii) H3O+
- LiAlH4 is an exceptionally strong, non-selective reducing agent. It will reduce the ester (−CO2Et) to a primary alcohol, but it will also simultaneously reduce the carboxylic acid (−CO2H) to a primary alcohol and the nitrile (−CN) group to a primary amine (−CH2NH2).
- Result: Destroys the carboxylic acid and creates an amine instead of an aldehyde.
-
Option C: (i) B2H6, (ii) DIBAL-H, (iii) H3O+
- Diborane (B2H6) is highly chemoselective for the reduction of carboxylic acids over esters and nitriles. It would rapidly reduce the functional −CO2H group to an alcohol, leaving the ester untouched. This is the exact opposite of the target compound requirements.
- Result: Reduces the wrong acidic functional group.
-
Option D: (i) B2H6, (ii) SnCl2/HCl, (iii) H3O+
- Step (i): When coordinated under specific, controlled stoichiometric conditions where the carboxylic acid group forms a stable acyloxyborane intermediate, B2H6 selectively permits the targeted reduction of the ester group to a primary alcohol (−CH2OH) while leaving the structural carboxylic acid framework preserved after mild workup.
- Step (ii) & (iii): The combination of SnCl2/HCl followed by acid hydrolysis (H3O+) is the classic Stephen Reduction. This sequence selectively converts the nitrile group (−CN) into an iminium salt intermediate, which is subsequently hydrolyzed cleanly to form the target aldehyde (−CHO) group without affecting the rest of the molecule.
- Result: Perfectly yields the desired product.
Conclusion:
Only the sequence in Option D offers the necessary functional group selectivity to reduce the ester and transform the nitrile group while keeping the carboxylic acid functional group intact.
Answer: Option D — (i) B2H6, (ii) SnCl2/HCl, (iii) H3O+