RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 01 SEP S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Chemistry question — Distinguishing tests for aldehydes and ketones

In the following sequence of reactions, C3_3H6_6 →H+/H2O\xrightarrow{H^+/H_2O} A →dilKOHKIO\xrightarrow[dil KOH]{KIO} B + C. The compounds B and C respectively are:

SOLUTION

We have the molecular formula C3H6\mathrm{C_3H_6}. In open-chain form, the only alkene possible is propene, written structurally as CH3−CH=CH2\mathrm{CH_3-CH=CH_2}.

The first reagent is aqueous acid, written as H+/H2O\mathrm{H^+/H_2O}. In the presence of dilute acid, an alkene undergoes electrophilic addition of water. The governing principle is Markovnikov’s rule: “When HX or H-OH adds to an unsymmetrical alkene, the hydrogen attaches to the doubly-bonded carbon already holding the larger number of hydrogens, and the other part (here -OH) goes to the other carbon.” Applying that rule to propene, the -OH group attaches to the middle carbon while the extra hydrogen attaches to the terminal carbon.

Writing every step symbolically,

CH3−CH=CH2  +  H+→      CH3−CH+−CH3\mathrm{CH_3-CH=CH_2 \;+\; H^+ \xrightarrow{\;\;}\; CH_3-CH^+-CH_3}$ CH3−CH+−CH3  +  H2O⟶CH3−CH(OH)−CH3+H+\mathrm{CH_3-CH^+-CH_3 \;+\; H_2O \longrightarrow CH_3-CH(OH)-CH_3 + H^+}$

Thus the product after the first step is CH3−CH(OH)−CH3\mathrm{CH_3-CH(OH)-CH_3}, i.e. propan-2-ol (commonly called isopropyl alcohol). Let us designate it as compound AA.

Now AA is treated with “KIO/dil  KOH\mathrm{KIO/dil\;KOH}”. In the laboratory the iodoform reaction is normally carried out with iodine and alkali (I2/KOH\mathrm{I_2/KOH}); I2\mathrm{I_2} in base actually produces the active species hypoiodite IO−\mathrm{IO^-}, so writing the reagent as KIO\mathrm{KIO} in dilute KOH\mathrm{KOH} conveys the same chemistry. The iodoform reaction occurs whenever the substrate contains either

(i) a methyl ketone group −CO−CH3\mathrm{ -CO-CH_3}, or
(ii) an alcohol that can be oxidised in situ to such a ketone, specifically R−CH(OH)−CH3\mathrm{R-CH(OH)-CH_3}.

Propan-2-ol fits criterion (ii) because it has the fragment −CH(OH)−CH3\mathrm{ -CH(OH)-CH_3}. The reaction sequence is:

1. Oxidation of the secondary alcohol to the corresponding methyl ketone (propan-2-one, acetone).

CH3−CH(OH)−CH3+[O]⟶CH3−CO−CH3+H2O\mathrm{CH_3-CH(OH)-CH_3 + [O] \longrightarrow CH_3-CO-CH_3 + H_2O}$

2. Successive iodination of the −CO−CH3\mathrm{ -CO-CH_3} group and base-promoted cleavage, giving yellow iodoform and a carboxylate anion whose carbon skeleton is the original ketone minus the iodine-bearing methyl group.

For acetone the detailed stoichiometry can be summarised as

CH3−CO−CH3+3 I2+4 KOH⟶CHI3↓+CH3COOK+3 KI+3 H2O\mathrm{CH_3-CO-CH_3 + 3\,I_2 + 4\,KOH \longrightarrow CHI_3 \downarrow + CH_3COOK + 3\,KI + 3\,H_2O}$

Therefore the two organic products obtained from the iodoform reaction of propan-2-ol are

CHI3(iodoform, a yellow solid)\mathrm{CHI_3} \quad\text{(iodoform, a yellow solid)}$

and

CH3COOK(potassium acetate)\mathrm{CH_3COOK} \quad\text{(potassium acetate)}$

Denoting them in the order given in the problem statement, we can identify

B=CHI3,C=CH3COOKB = \mathrm{CHI_3}, \qquad C = \mathrm{CH_3COOK}

Among the alternatives, only Option D lists the pair “CHI3\mathrm{CHI_3}, CH3COOK\mathrm{CH_3COOK}”.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Distinguishing tests for aldehydes and ketones. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicDistinguishing tests for aldehydes and ketones
TypeMultiple choice