Given below are two statements: Statement I: Acidity of α-hydrogens of aldehydes and ketones is responsible for Aldol reaction. Statement II: Reaction between benzaldehyde and ethanal will NOT give Cross-Aldol product. Choose the most appropriate answer from the options given below :
We need to evaluate the truth of two statements about the Aldol reaction.
Statement I: "Acidity of alpha-hydrogens of aldehydes and ketones is responsible for the Aldol reaction."
The Aldol reaction proceeds through the following mechanism:
1. A base abstracts an -hydrogen from one carbonyl compound, forming a resonance-stabilised enolate ion.
2. This enolate ion (a nucleophile) attacks the electrophilic carbonyl carbon of another molecule.
3. The resulting alkoxide is protonated to give the -hydroxy aldehyde (aldol product).
The entire reaction depends on the ability to form the enolate, which in turn requires that the -hydrogen be sufficiently acidic ( for typical aldehydes and ketones). Without acidic -hydrogens, the enolate cannot form and the Aldol reaction cannot proceed. Therefore, Statement I is correct.
Statement II: "Reaction between benzaldehyde and ethanal will NOT give a Cross-Aldol product."
Let us analyse the two reactants:
- Benzaldehyde (): This aldehyde has no -hydrogen (the carbon adjacent to is part of the benzene ring). Therefore, benzaldehyde cannot form an enolate and cannot act as the donor component.
- Ethanal (): This aldehyde has three -hydrogens on the methyl group. It can readily form an enolate ion.
In a cross-Aldol reaction between these two, ethanal provides the enolate (nucleophile), which attacks the carbonyl carbon of benzaldehyde (electrophile). This produces 3-hydroxy-3-phenylpropanal, which upon dehydration gives cinnamaldehyde (). This is a well-known reaction called the Claisen-Schmidt reaction.
Since the cross-Aldol product is formed, Statement II is incorrect.
The correct answer is Option 1: Statement I is correct but Statement II is incorrect.
Tagged Nucleophilic addition reactions of carbonyl compounds. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.