Key idea: A Grignard reagent adds to a carbonyl compound: HCHO gives a primary alcohol, other aldehydes give secondary, ketones give tertiary alcohols.
The target is the tertiary alcohol 2-phenylbutan-2-ol, CHX3CHX2−C(OH)(CHX3)−Ph. Its carbinol carbon carries CHX3, CX2HX5 and Ph.
- (B) PhCOCHX2CHX3+CHX3MgX: adds CHX3 to the ketone carbon → Ph−C(OH)(CHX3)CX2HX5. ✓
- (C) CHX3CHX2COCHX3+PhMgX: adds Ph → same alcohol. ✓
- (D) PhCOCHX3+CHX3CHX2MgX: adds ethyl → same alcohol. ✓
- (A) HCHO+PhCH(CHX3)CHX2MgX: formaldehyde always gives a primary alcohol, PhCH(CHX3)CHX2CHX2OH (3-phenylbutan-1-ol), not the tertiary target. ✗
Answer: (A)