RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2014 · 11 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2014 Chemistry question — Properties and reactions of alcohols

Which one of the following statements is not correct?

SOLUTION

We start by testing each of the four statements one by one, because the question asks us to find the single statement that is not correct.

Statement A says: “Alcohols are weaker acids than water.”

To compare acidities we use the definition pKa=−log⁡Ka.pK_a = -\log K_a. A larger pKapK_a means a smaller KaK_a and therefore a weaker acid. Experimentally we have

pKa(H2O)≈15.7,pK_a(\text{H}_2\text{O}) \approx 15.7, pKa(ROH)pK_a(\text{ROH}) (for a simple primary alcohol such as ethanol) ≈16–18.\approx 16\text{--}18.

Because 16−18>15.7,16-18 \gt 15.7, the pKapK_a of an alcohol is larger, so its KaK_a is smaller, hence an alcohol is indeed a weaker acid than water. Therefore Statement A is correct.

Statement B claims: “Acid strength of alcohols decreases in the order RCH2OH>R2CHOH>R3COH.\text{RCH}_2\text{OH} \gt \text{R}_2\text{CHOH} \gt \text{R}_3\text{COH}.”

Acidity depends on the stability of the conjugate base. After deprotonation an alkoxide ion RO−\text{RO}^- is formed. Alkyl groups are electron-donating by the inductive effect (+I).\left(+I\right). More alkyl groups push electron density toward oxygen, destabilising the negative charge. Hence:

• A primary alkoxide (RCH2O−)(\text{RCH}_2\text{O}^-) has one +I+I group.
• A secondary alkoxide (R2CHO−)(\text{R}_2\text{CHO}^-) has two +I+I groups and is less stable.
• A tertiary alkoxide (R3CO−)(\text{R}_3\text{CO}^-) has three +I+I groups and is the least stable.

Lower stability of the conjugate base means lower acidity of the conjugate acid, so the acid strength indeed falls in the sequence primary > secondary > tertiary. Hence Statement B is correct.

Statement C says: “Carbon-oxygen bond length in methanol, CH3OH,\text{CH}_3\text{OH}, is shorter than that of the C-O bond length in phenol.”

Let us recall typical experimental bond lengths:

• In methanol (a simple aliphatic alcohol) the C-O\text{C-O} bond is a pure single bond; its length is about 143 pm.143\ \text{pm}.
• In phenol, resonance causes partial double-bond character between the ring carbon and oxygen:

Ar-O-H      ⇌      Ar=O−−H+\text{Ar-O-H} \;\;\;\rightleftharpoons\;\;\; \text{Ar}=\text{O}^- -H^+

Because of this partial double-bond character the C-O\text{C-O} bond in phenol is shorter, about 136 pm.136\ \text{pm}. Numerically, 136 pm<143 pm,136\ \text{pm} \lt 143\ \text{pm}, so the bond in phenol is the shorter one. Statement C claims the opposite, therefore Statement C is not correct.

Statement D states: “The bond angle O-C-H in methanol is 108.9°.”

In methanol the carbon atom is sp3sp^3-hybridised. An ideal sp3sp^3 angle is 109.5∘.109.5^\circ. Slight differences arise because an O-C\text{O-C} bond and C-H\text{C-H} bonds are not identical in size or repulsion. Experimental gas-phase measurements give ∠(O-C-H)≈108.9∘,\angle(\text{O-C-H}) \approx 108.9^\circ, well within normal error of the ideal tetrahedral value. Therefore Statement D is correct.

Summarising our findings:

• A is correct, • B is correct, • C is incorrect, • D is correct.

Hence, the only statement that is not correct is Statement C, which corresponds to Option 3.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Properties and reactions of alcohols. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicProperties and reactions of alcohols
TypeMultiple choice