RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2023 · PAPER 2+3 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2023 Physics question — Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations

Young's modulus of elasticity YY is expressed in terms of three derived quantities, namely, the gravitational constant GG, Planck's constant hh and the speed of light c, as Y=cαhβGγY = c^\alpha h^\beta G^\gamma. Which of the following is the correct option?

SOLUTION

The dimensional formulae of the physical quantities are:

• Young’s modulus (stress): Y→M1L−1T−2Y \rightarrow M^{1}L^{-1}T^{-2}
• Speed of light: c→L1T−1c \rightarrow L^{1}T^{-1}
• Planck’s constant: h→M1L2T−1h \rightarrow M^{1}L^{2}T^{-1}
• Gravitational constant: G→M−1L3T−2G \rightarrow M^{-1}L^{3}T^{-2}

Assume Y=cαhβGγY = c^{\alpha}h^{\beta}G^{\gamma}. Equate the dimensions on both sides.

Step 1: Write combined dimensions on the right-hand side.
cα:LαT−αhβ:MβL2βT−βGγ:M−γL3γT−2γ\begin{aligned} c^{\alpha}&:&& L^{\alpha}T^{-\alpha}\\ h^{\beta}&:&& M^{\beta}L^{2\beta}T^{-\beta}\\ G^{\gamma}&:&& M^{-\gamma}L^{3\gamma}T^{-2\gamma} \end{aligned} Multiplying, M β−γ  L α+2β+3γ  T−α−β−2γM^{\,\beta-\gamma}\;L^{\,\alpha+2\beta+3\gamma}\;T^{-\alpha-\beta-2\gamma}

Step 2: Equate powers of M, L, TM,\,L,\,T with those of YY.

M:β−γ=  1  −(1)L:α+2β+3γ=  −1−(2)T:−α−β−2γ=  −2−(3)\begin{aligned} \text{M:}&\quad \beta-\gamma &=&\; 1\; \quad -(1)\\ \text{L:}&\quad \alpha+2\beta+3\gamma &=&\; -1\quad -(2)\\ \text{T:}&\quad -\alpha-\beta-2\gamma &=&\; -2\quad -(3) \end{aligned}

Step 3: Solve the simultaneous equations.

From (1):  β=1+γ(1):\; \beta = 1+\gamma.

Substitute in (3):  −α−(1+γ)−2γ=−2(3):\; -\alpha-(1+\gamma)-2\gamma = -2
⇒−α−1−3γ=−2\Rightarrow -\alpha-1-3\gamma = -2
⇒α+3γ=1−(4)\Rightarrow \alpha + 3\gamma = 1 \quad -(4)

Substitute β=1+γ\beta = 1+\gamma in (2):(2):
α+2(1+γ)+3γ=−1\alpha + 2(1+\gamma)+3\gamma = -1
⇒α+2+5γ=−1\Rightarrow \alpha + 2 + 5\gamma = -1
⇒α+5γ=−3−(5)\Rightarrow \alpha + 5\gamma = -3 \quad -(5)

Subtract (4)(4) from (5):(5):
(α+5γ)−(α+3γ)=−3−1(\alpha + 5\gamma) - (\alpha + 3\gamma) = -3 - 1
2γ=−4  ⇒  γ=−22\gamma = -4 \;\Rightarrow\; \gamma = -2

Insert γ=−2\gamma = -2 into (4):(4):
α+3(−2)=1  ⇒  α=7\alpha + 3(-2) = 1 \;\Rightarrow\; \alpha = 7

Insert γ=−2\gamma = -2 into β=1+γ\beta = 1+\gamma:
β=1−2=−1\beta = 1 - 2 = -1

Step 4: State the exponents.
α=7,  β=−1,  γ=−2\alpha = 7,\; \beta = -1,\; \gamma = -2

Hence, the correct choice is:
Option A which is: α=7,  β=−1,  γ=−2\alpha = 7,\; \beta = -1,\; \gamma = -2

Tagged Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicDimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations
TypeMultiple choice