RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2020 · PAPER 1+4 / −2MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2020 Physics question — Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations

Sometimes it is convenient to construct a system of units so that all quantities can be expressed in
terms of only one physical quantity. In one such system, dimensions of different quantities are given
in terms of a quantity X as follows: [position]=[𝑋α];[speed]=[𝑋β];[acceleration]=[𝑋p];[linearmomentum]=[𝑋q];[force]=[𝑋r][position] = [𝑋^{\alpha}]; [speed] = [𝑋^{\beta}]; [acceleration] =[𝑋^{p}]; [linear momentum] = [𝑋^{q}]; [force] = [𝑋^{r}]. Then

SOLUTION

Only one fundamental dimension [X][X] is allowed, so every physical quantity must appear as some power of XX.

Let the dimensions of time and mass be [T]=[Xτ][T]=[X^{\tau}] and [M]=[Xμ][M]=[X^{\mu}] respectively.
Given data (powers of XX):
  • position : α\alpha  • speed : β\beta  • acceleration : pp
  • linear momentum : qq  • force : rr

Step 1: Relate α,  β,  p\alpha,\;\beta,\;p using kinematics.
Speed = position / time  ⇒\Rightarrow  Xβ=Xα / Xτ  X^{\beta}=X^{\alpha}\,/\,X^{\tau}\; ⇒\Rightarrow τ=α−β\tau=\alpha-\beta.
Acceleration = speed / time  ⇒\Rightarrow  Xp=Xβ / Xτ=Xβ−(α−β)=X2β−αX^{p}=X^{\beta}\,/\,X^{\tau}=X^{\beta-(\alpha-\beta)}=X^{2\beta-\alpha}.
Hence p=2β−α−(1)p = 2\beta - \alpha \quad -(1).

Re-arranging (1)(1) gives α+p−2β=0\alpha+p-2\beta=0, so the quantity given in Option A is identically zero; Option A is therefore correct.

Step 2: Bring in mass via momentum and force.
Linear momentum = mass × velocity  ⇒\Rightarrow  Xq=Xμ Xβ=Xμ+βX^{q}=X^{\mu}\,X^{\beta}=X^{\mu+\beta}, thus q=μ+β−(2)q=\mu+\beta \quad -(2).
Force = mass × acceleration  ⇒\Rightarrow  Xr=Xμ Xp=Xμ+pX^{r}=X^{\mu}\,X^{p}=X^{\mu+p}, thus r=μ+p−(3)r=\mu+p \quad -(3).

Step 3: Test the remaining options.

Option B claims  p+q−r=βp+q-r=\beta.
Using (2),(3):(2),(3): p+q−r=p+(μ+β)−(μ+p)=β,p+q-r = p+(\mu+\beta) - (\mu+p) = \beta, which is true. Hence Option B is correct.

Option C claims  p−q+r=αp-q+r=\alpha.
Left-hand side = p−(μ+β)+(μ+p)=2p−βp-(\mu+\beta)+(\mu+p)=2p-\beta.
With (1):(1): 2p−β=2(2β−α)−β=3β−2α,2p-\beta = 2(2\beta-\alpha)-\beta = 3\beta-2\alpha, which equals α\alpha only if α=β\alpha=\beta, not guaranteed. So Option C is not necessarily true.

Option D claims  p+q+r=βp+q+r=\beta.
Left-hand side = p+(μ+β)+(μ+p)=2p+2μ+β,p+(\mu+\beta)+(\mu+p)=2p+2\mu+\beta, which cannot reduce to β\beta for arbitrary μ,p\mu,p. Hence Option D is incorrect.

Therefore the correct relations are given by Option A and Option B.

Final Answer: Option A and Option B.

Tagged Dimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicDimensional analysis: deriving and checking relations
TypeMultiple correct