RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2022 · PAPER 2+4 / −2HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2022 Physics question — Angle of contact and capillary rise

A bubble has surface tension SS. The ideal gas inside the bubble has ratio of specific heats γ=53\gamma = \dfrac{5}{3}. The bubble is exposed to the atmosphere and it always retains its spherical shape. When the atmospheric pressure is Pa1P_{a1}, the radius of the bubble is found to be r1r_1 and the temperature of the enclosed gas is T1T_1. When the atmospheric pressure is Pa2P_{a2}, the radius of the bubble and the temperature of the enclosed gas are r2r_2 and T2T_2, respectively.

Which of the following statement(s) is(are) correct?

SOLUTION

For a thin soap bubble in air, the excess pressure due to surface tension is 4Sr\dfrac{4S}{r} (two surfaces of the film). Hence at any instant

P=Pa+4SrP = P_a + \dfrac{4S}{r}

where PaP_a is the atmospheric pressure, PP the gas pressure inside the bubble and rr the instantaneous radius.

Case 1: Surface is a perfect heat insulator (adiabatic process)

The enclosed gas obeys the adiabatic relation

PVγ=constantPV^{\gamma}= \text{constant}

with γ=53\gamma = \dfrac{5}{3} and V=4πr33    (∴V∝r3)V=\dfrac{4\pi r^{3}}{3} \;\;(\therefore V\propto r^{3}).

Therefore

(Pa+4Sr)  r3γ=constant\bigl(P_a+\dfrac{4S}{r}\bigr)\;r^{3\gamma}= \text{constant}

⇒  (Pa1+4Sr1) r15=(Pa2+4Sr2) r25\Rightarrow\; \bigl(P_{a1}+\dfrac{4S}{r_1}\bigr)\,r_1^{5} =\bigl(P_{a2}+\dfrac{4S}{r_2}\bigr)\,r_2^{5}

⇒  (r1r2)5=Pa2+4Sr2Pa1+4Sr1\Rightarrow\; \left(\dfrac{r_1}{r_2}\right)^{5}= \dfrac{P_{a2}+ \dfrac{4S}{r_2}}{P_{a1}+ \dfrac{4S}{r_1}}

• Option A uses 2S/r2S/r instead of 4S/r4S/r, so Option A is wrong.

Next, relate temperature using the ideal-gas law PV=nRTPV = nRT.

Combining PV=nRTPV = nRT with PVγ=constantPV^{\gamma}= \text{constant} gives the standard result for an adiabatic change

TVγ−1=constantTV^{\gamma-1}= \text{constant}

Since γ−1=23\gamma-1=\dfrac{2}{3}, we get Tr2=constantT r^{2}= \text{constant}, i.e.

T2T1=(r1r2)2\dfrac{T_2}{T_1}= \left(\dfrac{r_1}{r_2}\right)^{2}

Raising both sides to the power 52\dfrac{5}{2} and substituting the radius relation derived earlier:

(T2T1)5/2=(r1r2)5=Pa2+4Sr2Pa1+4Sr1\left(\dfrac{T_2}{T_1}\right)^{5/2}= \left(\dfrac{r_1}{r_2}\right)^{5}= \dfrac{P_{a2}+ \dfrac{4S}{r_2}}{P_{a1}+ \dfrac{4S}{r_1}}

This is exactly the statement in Option D, so Option D is correct.

The total energy of the system is

Utotal=Ugas+Esurface=nCVT+4πr2SU_{\text{total}} = U_{\text{gas}} + E_{\text{surface}} = nC_{V}T + 4\pi r^{2}S

Both TT and rr change during the adiabatic compression/expansion, hence UtotalU_{\text{total}} is not constant. Therefore Option B is wrong.

Case 2: Surface is a perfect heat conductor (isothermal process)

If heat flows freely through the film while the surrounding temperature remains nearly unchanged, the gas undergoes an isothermal change so that PV=constant.PV=\text{constant}. Using V∝r3V\propto r^{3}:

(Pa+4Sr) r3=constant\bigl(P_a+\dfrac{4S}{r}\bigr)\,r^{3}= \text{constant}

⇒  (r1r2)3=Pa2+4Sr2Pa1+4Sr1\Rightarrow\; \left(\dfrac{r_1}{r_2}\right)^{3}= \dfrac{P_{a2}+ \dfrac{4S}{r_2}}{P_{a1}+ \dfrac{4S}{r_1}}

This matches Option C exactly, so Option C is correct.

Hence the correct statements are:
Option C and Option D.

Tagged Angle of contact and capillary rise. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicAngle of contact and capillary rise
TypeMultiple correct