RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2020 · PAPER 1+4 / −2MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2020 Physics question — Ideal gas equation and gas laws

As shown schematically in the figure, two vessels contain water solutions (at temperature 𝑇) of
potassium permanganate (KMnO4KMnO_{4}) of different concentrations n1n_{1} and n2(n1>n2)n_{2} (n_{1} > n_{2}) molecules per unit volume with △n=(n1−n2)<<n1\triangle n = (n_{1} − n_{2}) << n_{1}. When they are connected by a tube of small length l and cross-sectional area S, KMnO4KMnO_{4} starts to diffuse from the left to the right vessel through the tube. Consider the collection of molecules to behave as dilute ideal gases and the difference in their partial pressure in the two vessels causing the diffusion. The speed 𝑣 of the molecules is limited by the viscous force −βvoneachmolecule,where−\beta v on each molecule, where\betaisaconstant.Neglectingalltermsoftheorderis a constant. Neglecting all terms of the order\left(\tirangle n\right)^{2},whichofthefollowingis/arecorrect?(, which of the following is/are correct? (k_{B}$$ is the Boltzmann constant)

Figure for JEE Advanced 2020 Physics question on Ideal gas equation and gas laws
SOLUTION

For a very dilute solution each solute molecule behaves like an ideal-gas particle, so its partial pressure obeys the ideal-gas relation

P=nkBTP = nk_B T

where nn is the number of molecules per unit volume and TT is the (common) temperature of the two vessels.

The left vessel contains n1n_1 molecules per unit volume, the right one n2n_2 with n1>n2n_1 \gt n_2 and Δn=n1−n2≪n1\Delta n = n_1-n_2 \ll n_1.

Force that drives the molecules (Option A)
The difference in partial pressure is

ΔP=(n1−n2)kBT=Δn kBT\Delta P = (n_1-n_2)k_B T = \Delta n\,k_B T

and it acts over the cross-sectional area SS of the connecting tube, so the net driving force is

Fdrive=ΔP S=Δn kBT SF_{\text{drive}} = \Delta P\,S = \Delta n\,k_B T\,S

Thus Option A is correct.

Force balance in the tube (Option B)
Inside the tube (length ll, area SS) the solute molecules acquire a steady drift speed vv. Each molecule experiences the viscous drag −βv-\beta v, so the total drag force on the molecules present in the tube is

Fdrag=(number of molecules in tube)×βvF_{\text{drag}} = (\text{number of molecules in tube})\times\beta v

The number of solute molecules in the tube is the concentration times its volume:

(number)=n1 (Sl)(\text{number}) = n_1\,(S l)

(we may replace the concentration everywhere by n1n_1 because Δn≪n1\Delta n\ll n_1 and we are neglecting all O((Δn)2)\mathcal{O}((\Delta n)^2) terms).

Hence

Fdrag=n1 Sl βvF_{\text{drag}} = n_1\,S l\,\beta v

In steady state, driving force equals drag:

n1 Sl βv=Δn kBT Sn_1\,S l\,\beta v = \Delta n\,k_B T\,S

or

n1 β v l=Δn kBTn_1\,\beta\,v\,l = \Delta n\,k_B T

This is exactly the relation given in Option B, so Option B is correct.

Number of molecules crossing per second (Option C)
The flux (number per unit time) through the tube equals concentration × drift speed × area:

R=n1 v SR = n_1\,v\,S

Using the velocity from the force-balance equation:

v=Δn kBTn1 β lv = \frac{\Delta n\,k_B T}{n_1\,\beta\,l}

we get

R=n1 S(Δn kBTn1 β l)=Δn kBT Sβ lR = n_1\,S\left(\frac{\Delta n\,k_B T}{n_1\,\beta\,l}\right) = \frac{\Delta n\,k_B T\,S}{\beta\,l}

Option C quotes (Δnl)(kBTβ)\displaystyle\left(\frac{\Delta n}{l}\right)\left(\frac{k_B T}{\beta}\right), which is missing the factor SS, so Option C is incorrect.

Time-dependence of the transfer rate (Option D)
The rate found above is proportional to Δn\Delta n. As diffusion proceeds, n1n_1 decreases and n2n_2 increases, so Δn\Delta n steadily falls and the rate correspondingly decreases. Therefore the transfer rate is not constant in time; Option D is incorrect.

Hence the correct statements are:
Option A and Option B.

Tagged Ideal gas equation and gas laws. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicIdeal gas equation and gas laws
TypeMultiple correct