RankRizz
JEE ADVANCED 2008 · PAPER 2MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Advanced 2008 Chemistry question — Geometrical and optical isomerism in complexes

STATEMENT-1: The geometrical isomers of the complex [M(NH3)4Cl2][M(NH_3)_4Cl_2] are optically inactive.
and
STATEMENT-2: Both geometrical isomers of the complex [M(NH3)4Cl2][M(NH_3)_4Cl_2] possess axis of symmetry.

SOLUTION

Key idea: A molecule is optically inactive if it has a plane (or centre) of symmetry, i.e. an improper axis. A simple rotation axis does not guarantee that it is achiral.

  1. [MAX4BX2]\ce{[MA4B2]} has two geometrical isomers, cis and trans.
  2. trans: has a C4C_4 axis along Cl–M–Cl, several mirror planes and a centre of symmetry, so it is achiral.
  3. cis: has a C2C_2 axis and two mirror planes (each containing M and both Cl, or bisecting them), so it is achiral.
  4. Statement-1 is true and Statement-2 is true (both have an axis of symmetry).
  5. But having an axis is not why they are inactive: chiral molecules such as [Co(en)X3]X3+\ce{[Co(en)3]^3+} also have C2C_2/C3C_3 axes. Optical inactivity comes from the mirror planes.

Answer: (B)

Tagged Geometrical and optical isomerism in complexes. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectChemistry
TopicGeometrical and optical isomerism in complexes
TypeMultiple choice