Complete reaction of acetaldehyde with excess formaldehyde, upon heating with conc. NaOH solution, gives P and Q. Compound P does not give Tollens' test, whereas Q on acidification gives positive Tollens' test. Treatment of P with excess cyclohexanone in the presence of catalytic amount of p-toluenesulfonic acid (PTSA) gives product R.
Sum of the number of methylene groups () and oxygen atoms in R is ______.
The reaction sequence is a standard industrial route to the poly-alcohol pentaerythritol and its ketal derivatives. We analyse every step.
Step 1 : Reaction of acetaldehyde with excess formaldehyde in conc. NaOH
• Formaldehyde has no -hydrogen, so in strong alkali it undergoes the Cannizzaro reaction:
• In the presence of acetaldehyde, a cross-Cannizzaro/Aldol sequence occurs.
1 mol acetaldehyde first gives an enolate which adds to two molecules of formaldehyde (cross-aldol).
The aldehydic group thus produced is then reduced by hydride transfer from a third molecule of formaldehyde (Cannizzaro step).
The overall stoichiometry is
• The poly-alcohol obtained is pentaerythritol, . It possesses no -CHO group, hence it does not respond to Tollens’ reagent.
• The salt on acidification furnishes formic acid, , which does reduce Tollens’ reagent. Thus the statements regarding and are consistent.
Step 2 : Ketal formation between and excess cyclohexanone in the presence of catalytic p-toluenesulfonic acid (PTSA)
Acid catalyses the reaction of a ketone with two alcohol functions to give a ketal.
Each molecule of cyclohexanone requires two -OH groups:
Pentaerythritol has four -OH groups, therefore it can furnish the necessary two alcohol units twice. Consequently, with excess cyclohexanone it forms a diketal:
Each pair originates from one molecule of cyclohexanone, so contains two cyclohexanone rings attached through ketal linkages.
Counting -CH2- groups in
• Central pentaerythritol carbon: four groups
• Each cyclohexanone ring (after ketal formation) supplies five groups
(the carbonyl carbon becomes quaternary, carries no hydrogens).
Two rings
Total methylene groups
Counting oxygen atoms in
Every ketal linkage contains the two original alcohol oxygens; thus the four -OH groups of pentaerythritol become four ether oxygens. (The carbonyl oxygens of the ketones are lost as water during ketalisation).
Total oxygen atoms
Required sum
Therefore, the asked sum is 18.
Tagged Nucleophilic addition reactions of carbonyl compounds. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.