Key idea: R is the crossed aldol product of isobutyraldehyde and formaldehyde.
- In aqueous KX2COX3, (CHX3)X2CHCHO forms an enolate at its single α-carbon.
- The enolate attacks HCHO, which is the more reactive carbonyl and has no α-H:
(CHX3)X2CX−CHO+HCHOHOCHX2−C(CHX3)X2−CHO
- The product, 3-hydroxy-2,2-dimethylpropanal, has no α-H left, so it cannot dehydrate further. It stays as the β-hydroxy aldehyde.
- This matches option (A), a quaternary C bearing 2CHX3, CHO and CHX2OH.
Answer: (A)