Key idea: In the Reimer–Tiemann reaction the phenoxide attacks dichlorocarbene, so the intermediate carries a − C H C l X 2 \ce{-CHCl2} − CHCl X 2 group ortho to O X − \ce{O-} O X − .
C H C l X 3 + N a O H → : C C l X 2 \ce{CHCl3 + NaOH -> :CCl2} CHCl X 3 + NaOH : CCl X 2 (dichlorocarbene, electrophilic).
The phenoxide of p-cresol attacks : C C l X 2 \ce{:CCl2} : CCl X 2 at the ortho position. A proton shift (re-aromatisation) then gives the ortho-C H C l X 2 \ce{CHCl2} CHCl X 2 phenoxide, which is intermediate I.
Aqueous NaOH hydrolyses − C H C l X 2 → − C H ( O H ) X 2 → − C H O \ce{-CHCl2 -> -CH(OH)2 -> -CHO} − CHCl X 2 − CH ( OH ) X 2 − CHO , giving 2-hydroxy-5-methylbenzaldehyde.
− C H X 2 C l \ce{-CH2Cl} − CH X 2 Cl (A) or − C H X 2 O H \ce{-CH2OH} − CH X 2 OH (D) would need a C H X 2 \ce{CH2} CH X 2 unit, and − C C l X 3 \ce{-CCl3} − CCl X 3 (C) would come from C C l X 4 \ce{CCl4} CCl X 4 .
Answer: (B), the ortho-C H C l X 2 \ce{CHCl2} CHCl X 2 sodium phenoxide