Here 4 graphs are given and were asked to be arranged in descending order of work done
We know that work done in an F-x graph is equal to the area under the curve.
-
Area above x-axis → positive work
-
Area below x-axis → negative work
-
Net work = (positive area − negative area)
Graph (1);-
Here work done W1 is area of this graph which is combination of 2 triangles
One from 0 to x0 with a Force of -F
Another from x0 to x1 with a Force of F
Here both are triangles, so area is
Net Area = W1 = 2 1× −F× (x0−0) + 2 1× F× (x1−x0)
Net Area = W1 = −2 1Fx0 + 2 1 F (x1−x0)
Graph (2);-
Here work done W2 is area of this graph which is combination of 2 triangles and one rectangle
One triangle from 0 to x0 with a Force of -F
Another triangle from x0 to x1 with a Force of F
Rectangle from x1to x2 with a Force of F
So area is
Net Area = W2 = 2 1× −F× (x0−0) + 2 1× F× (x1−x0) + F× (x2−x1)
Net Area = W2 = −2 1Fx0 + 2 1 F (x1−x0) + F(x2−x1)
Graph (3);-
Here work done W3 is area of this graph which is combination of 3 triangles and one rectangle
First triangle from 0 to x0 with a Force of -F
Second from x0 to x1 with a Force of F
Third from x2 to x3 with a Force of F
Rectangle from x1to x2 with a Force of F
So area is,
Net Area = W3 = 2 1× −F× (x0−0) + 2 1× F× (x1−x0) + F× (x2−x1) + 2 1× F× (x3−x2)
Net Area = W3 = −2 1Fx0 + 2 1 F (x1−x0) + F(x2−x1) + 2 1 F (x3−x2)
Graph (4);-
Here work done W4 is area of this graph which is combination of 3 triangles and one rectangle
One from 0 to x0 with a Force of F
Another from x0 to x1 with a Force of -F
Rectangle from x1to x2 with a Force of -F
Another from x2 to x3 with a Force of F
So area is,
Net Area = W4 = 2 1× F× (x0−0) + 2 1× −F× (x1−x0) + −F× (x2−x1) + 2 1× F× (x3−x2)
Net Area = W4 = 2 1 F (x0−0) − 2 1 F (x1−x0) + −F (x2−x1) + 2 1 F (x3−x2)
W2has an extra positive rectangular area compared to W1
⇒ W2>W1
W3 has an additional positive triangular area compared to W2
⇒ W3>W2
W4 contains a negative rectangular term and a negative triangular term -\ \ \ \frac{\ 1}{2}\ F\ \left(x_1-x_0\right)\ +\ -F\ \left(x_2-x_1\right)\ which reduces total work significantly
⇒ W4<W1
Final answer :- W3>W2>W1>W4
So option (1) is correct.