RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2012TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2012 Physics question — Work done by constant and variable forces

This question has statement 1 and statement 2. Of the four choices given after the statements, choose the one that best describes the two statements. If two springs S1S_1 and S2S_2 of force constants k1k_1 and k2k_2, respectively, are stretched by the same force, it is found that more work is done on spring S1S_1 than on spring S2S_2. Statement 1: If stretched by the same amount, work done on S1S_1, will be more than that on S2S_2. Statement 2: k1<k2k_1 < k_2

SOLUTION

The elastic potential energy (work done) stored in an ideal spring is given by
W=12kx2W = \tfrac12 k x^{2}

When the same external force FF is applied on two springs, the extensions become x1=Fk1x_1 = \dfrac{F}{k_1} and x2=Fk2x_2 = \dfrac{F}{k_2}. Substituting in the energy formula, the work done on each spring is
W1=12k1x12=12k1(Fk1)2=F22k1W_1 = \tfrac12 k_1 x_1^{2} = \tfrac12 k_1\left(\dfrac{F}{k_1}\right)^{2} = \dfrac{F^{2}}{2k_1}
W2=F22k2W_2 = \dfrac{F^{2}}{2k_2}

Because W1>W2W_1 \gt W_2 is given, we must have F22k1>F22k2  ⇒  k1<k2\dfrac{F^{2}}{2k_1} \gt \dfrac{F^{2}}{2k_2}\; \Rightarrow\; k_1 \lt k_2 so Statement 2 is true.

Next consider stretching each spring through the same extension xx. The work done is directly proportional to the force constant: W=12kx2W = \tfrac12 k x^{2} With k1<k2k_1 \lt k_2 we would get W1<W2W_1 \lt W_2, not more. Therefore Statement 1 is false.

Statement 2 is true while Statement 1 is false. Hence
Option A which is: Statement 1 is false, Statement 2 is true

Tagged Work done by constant and variable forces. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicWork done by constant and variable forces
TypeMultiple choice