RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 07 JAN S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Doppler effect in sound

A stationary observer receives sound from two identical tuning forks, one of which approaches and the other one recedes with the same speed (much less than the speed of sound). The observer hears 2 beats/sec. The oscillation frequency of each tuning fork is v0=1400v_0 = 1400 Hz and the velocity of sound in air is 350 m/s. The speed of each tuning fork is close to:

SOLUTION

We start with the standard Doppler-effect formula for the apparent frequency heard by a stationary observer when the source itself is moving. If the source of true frequency v0v_0 moves with speed uu and the speed of sound in air is vv, then

• when the source moves towards the observer, the apparent frequency is

vtowards=v0 v v−u v_{\text{towards}} = v_0 \,\frac{v}{\,v - u\,}

• when the source moves away from the observer, the apparent frequency is

vaway=v0 v v+u v_{\text{away}} = v_0 \,\frac{v}{\,v + u\,}

In the present situation both forks are identical, each having natural frequency v0=1400 Hzv_0 = 1400\ \text{Hz}. One fork approaches the observer with speed uu while the other recedes with the same speed uu. Therefore, the observer hears two different apparent frequencies:

v1=v0 vv−uandv2=v0 vv+u.v_1 = v_0 \,\frac{v}{v - u} \qquad\text{and}\qquad v_2 = v_0 \,\frac{v}{v + u}.

The beat frequency is the absolute difference between these two apparent frequencies. By definition,

Beat frequency =∣ v1−v2 ∣.\text{Beat frequency } = |\,v_1 - v_2\,|.

According to the question, the observer hears 2 beats per second, so

∣ v1−v2 ∣=2 Hz.|\,v_1 - v_2\,| = 2\ \text{Hz}.

Let us compute the difference algebraically. Substituting the expressions for v1v_1 and v2v_2, we have

∣ v1−v2 ∣=v0∣vv−u−vv+u∣.|\,v_1 - v_2\,| = v_0\Bigl|\frac{v}{v - u} - \frac{v}{v + u}\Bigr|.

Combining the two fractions inside the absolute value gives

vv−u−vv+u=v[ v+u−(v−u) (v−u)(v+u)]=v[2uv2−u2].\frac{v}{v - u} - \frac{v}{v + u} = v\left[\frac{\,v + u - (v - u)\,}{(v - u)(v + u)}\right] = v\left[\frac{2u}{v^2 - u^2}\right].

Hence

∣ v1−v2 ∣=v0⋅v⋅2uv2−u2.|\,v_1 - v_2\,| = v_0 \cdot v \cdot \frac{2u}{v^2 - u^2}.

The speed of each fork is said to be “much less than the speed of sound,” i.e. u≪vu \ll v. Under this condition u2u^2 is negligibly small compared with v2v^2, so we may approximate

(v2−u2)≈v2.(v^2 - u^2) \approx v^2.

Substituting this approximation simplifies the expression for the beat frequency to

∣ v1−v2 ∣≈v0⋅v⋅2uv2=2v0uv.|\,v_1 - v_2\,| \approx v_0 \cdot v \cdot \frac{2u}{v^2} = \frac{2v_0u}{v}.

Setting this equal to the observed 2 beats per second gives a single linear equation for uu:

2v0uv=2.\frac{2v_0u}{v} = 2.

Dividing both sides by 2 yields

v0uv=1.\frac{v_0u}{v} = 1.

Now solving for uu, we multiply both sides by vv and divide by v0v_0:

u=vv0.u = \frac{v}{v_0}.

We substitute the numerical values, v=350 m/sv = 350\ \text{m/s} and v0=1400 Hzv_0 = 1400\ \text{Hz}:

u=3501400 m/s=0.25 m/s.u = \frac{350}{1400}\ \text{m/s} = 0.25\ \text{m/s}.

The fraction 0.250.25 is exactly 14\tfrac14, so the speed of each tuning fork is 14 m/s\tfrac14\ \text{m/s}.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Doppler effect in sound. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
ChapterWaves
TopicDoppler effect in sound
TypeMultiple choice