The air column behaves as a pipe closed at the water-surface end and open at the top end.
For a pipe closed at one end, the resonance (standing-wave) condition is
Leff=4(2n−1)λ,n=1,2,3,…
where Leff is the effective length of the air column and λ the wavelength of sound.
Because the open end is not a sharp boundary, the antinode actually forms a little outside the tube.
That shift is the end-correction e(≈0.6r), so
Leff=L+e
where L is the measured (geometrical) length of air in the tube.
Given two successive resonances at
L1=16 cm=0.16 m,L2=50 cm=0.50 m,
the difference between successive resonant lengths of a closed pipe is
L_2-L_1 = \frac{\lambda}{2}\; \Longrightarrow \; \lambda = 2(L_2-L_1) = 2(0.50-0.16)=0.68\text{ m}.$</p>
<p>The speed of sound in air is therefore</p>
<p>v = f\,λ = 500\,Hz×0.68\,m=340\;m s−1.</p><p>Usingthefirstresonance(n=1)toobtaintheendcorrection:</p><p>L_{eff} = 4λ=40.68=0.17 m,e = L_{eff}-L_1 = 0.17-0.16 = 0.01 m = 1 cm.</p><p>Whenthetubeistakenoutofwater,bothendsareopen.Forapipeopenatbothends,thestanding−waveconditionis</p><p>L_{eff(open)} = 2nλ,\qquad n = 1,2,3,\dots</p><p>Nowtheantinodeshiftoccursatbothends,so</p><p>L_{eff(open)} = L_0 + 2e,</p><p>whereL_0 = 60.5 cm=0.605 mistheactuallengthofthetubeinair.</p><p>HenceL_{eff(open)} = 0.605 + 2(0.01) = 0.625 m.</p><p>Thefundamentalfrequency(n=1)fortheopenpipeis</p><p>f_1 = \frac{v}{2L_{\text{eff(open)}}} = 2×0.625340=1.25340≈272 Hz.</p><p>Thenexthigherresonantfrequency(n=2)issimplydoublethefundamental:</p><p>f_2 = 2f_1 ≈ 2×272 = 544 Hz.</p><p>Therefore,thetwolowestfrequenciestowhichthetubewillresonatewhenitiscompletelyinairareapproximately272 Hzand544 Hz.</p><p>OptionDwhichis:272, 544$$