RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2018 · 16 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2018 Physics question — Superposition, interference and beats

Two sitar strings, A and B playing the note 'Dha' are slightly out of tune and produce beats of frequency 5 Hz. The tension of the string B is slightly increased and the beat frequency is found to decrease by 3 Hz. If the frequency of A is 425 Hz. The original frequency of B is:

SOLUTION

We are given that string A has frequency fA=425 Hzf_A = 425\ \text{Hz} and, when it is sounded together with string B, a beat frequency of 5 Hz5\ \text{Hz} is heard.

First, we recall the definition of beat frequency:

fbeat=∣ fA−fB ∣f_{\text{beat}} = \left|\,f_A - f_B\,\right|

Here fbeat=5 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = 5\ \text{Hz}, so

∣ 425−fB ∣=5\left|\,425 - f_B\,\right| = 5

Solving this absolute-value equation gives two algebraic possibilities:

425−fB=5⟹fB=420 Hz425 - f_B = 5 \quad \Longrightarrow \quad f_B = 420\ \text{Hz} 425−fB=−5⟹fB=430 Hz425 - f_B = -5 \quad \Longrightarrow \quad f_B = 430\ \text{Hz}

Thus, before we touch the tension, B could be either 420 Hz420\ \text{Hz} or 430 Hz430\ \text{Hz}.

Next, the tension of B is slightly increased. The fundamental frequency of a stretched string is given by the formula

f=12LTμf = \frac{1}{2L}\sqrt{\frac{T}{\mu}}

where LL is the length, TT is the tension, and μ\mu is the linear mass density. We see that f∝Tf \propto \sqrt{T}, so increasing tension always increases the frequency of the string.

Experimentally, after increasing the tension, the beat frequency is observed to decrease by 3 Hz3\ \text{Hz}. The old beat frequency was 5 Hz5\ \text{Hz}, so the new beat frequency is

fbeat′=5−3=2 Hzf'_{\text{beat}} = 5 - 3 = 2\ \text{Hz}

This means the new frequency difference satisfies

∣ fA−fB′ ∣=2 Hz\left|\,f_A - f'_B\,\right| = 2\ \text{Hz}

Since increasing tension can only raise fBf_B, let us test each of the two earlier possibilities:

1. If the original fB=430 Hzf_B = 430\ \text{Hz} (already higher than 425 Hz), raising the tension would further increase it, say to fB′>430 Hzf'_B > 430\ \text{Hz}. The new difference ∣425−fB′∣|425 - f'_B| would then be greater than ∣425−430∣=5 Hz|425 - 430| = 5\ \text{Hz}, so the beat frequency would rise above 5 Hz, not drop to 2 Hz. This contradicts the observation.

2. If the original fB=420 Hzf_B = 420\ \text{Hz} (lower than 425 Hz), raising the tension lifts it closer to 425 Hz, perhaps to fB′=423 Hzf'_B = 423\ \text{Hz}. The new difference ∣425−423∣=2 Hz|425 - 423| = 2\ \text{Hz} is indeed smaller than 5 Hz, exactly matching the measured decrease to 2 Hz.

Therefore the only self-consistent choice is

fB=420 Hzf_B = 420\ \text{Hz}

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Superposition, interference and beats. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
ChapterWaves
TopicSuperposition, interference and beats
TypeMultiple choice