RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2016 · 10 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2016 Physics question — Doppler effect in sound

A toy-car, blowing its horn, is moving with a steady speed of 5 m s−1^{-1}, away from a wall. An observer, towards whom the toy car is moving, is able to hear 5 beats per second. If the velocity of sound in air is 340 m s−1^{-1}, the frequency of the horn of the toy car is close to

SOLUTION

Let the true frequency of the horn of the toy-car be f  Hzf\;{\rm Hz}. The speed of sound in air is given to be v=340  m s−1v = 340\;{\rm m\,s^{-1}} and the speed of the toy-car is u=5  m s−1u = 5\;{\rm m\,s^{-1}}.

The observer receives sound by two different paths:

1. Direct sound from the horn.   The toy-car (source) is moving towards the observer.   For a stationary observer and a moving source, the Doppler-shift formula is

fobserved=vv−us f,f_{\text{observed}} = \frac{v}{v - u_s}\,f,

where usu_s is the speed of the source towards the observer. Here us=u=5  m s−1u_s = u = 5\;{\rm m\,s^{-1}}, so the frequency heard directly is

f1=vv−u f=340340−5 f=340335 f.f_1 = \frac{v}{v - u}\,f = \frac{340}{340 - 5}\,f = \frac{340}{335}\,f.

2. Reflected sound from the wall (echo).   First, the sound reaches the wall. The car is moving away from the wall, so for the wall (which is a stationary observer) the received frequency is

fwall=vv+u f=340340+5 f=340345 f.f_{\text{wall}} = \frac{v}{v + u}\,f = \frac{340}{340 + 5}\,f = \frac{340}{345}\,f.

The wall is at rest, so it reflects this sound without any further Doppler shift; the wall now behaves as a stationary source emitting frequency fwallf_{\text{wall}}. Because the final observer is also stationary, the frequency finally heard from the echo remains

f2=fwall=340345 f.f_2 = f_{\text{wall}} = \frac{340}{345}\,f.

The observer hears beats produced by the superposition of the direct sound (f1f_1) and the reflected sound (f2f_2). The beat frequency equals the absolute difference of the two frequencies, and this is given as 5 beats per second:

∣ f1−f2 ∣=5.|\,f_1 - f_2\,| = 5.

Explicitly substituting f1f_1 and f2f_2 we get

∣ 340335 f−340345 f ∣=5.\left|\,\frac{340}{335}\,f - \frac{340}{345}\,f\,\right| = 5.

Pulling out the common factor 340f340f gives

340f∣ 1335−1345 ∣=5.340f\left|\,\frac{1}{335} - \frac{1}{345}\,\right| = 5.

The difference inside the modulus is

1335−1345=345−335335×345=10335×345.\frac{1}{335} - \frac{1}{345} = \frac{345 - 335}{335 \times 345} = \frac{10}{335 \times 345}.

Therefore,

340f×10335×345=5.340f \times \frac{10}{335 \times 345} = 5.

We now solve for ff step by step:

f=5×335×345340×10.f = 5 \times \frac{335 \times 345}{340 \times 10}.

Simplifying the numerator and denominator,

f=5×335×3453400.f = 5 \times \frac{335 \times 345}{3400}. f=53400×335×345.f = \frac{5}{3400} \times 335 \times 345. f=5×335×3453400.f = \frac{5 \times 335 \times 345}{3400}.

Take out the common factor 5 from 3400:

f=335×345680.f = \frac{335 \times 345}{680}.

Now divide 335 by 5 to make the arithmetic easier:

335=5×67,335 = 5 \times 67, so substitute:

f=(5×67)×345680=5×67×3455×136f = \frac{(5 \times 67) \times 345}{680} = \frac{5 \times 67 \times 345}{5 \times 136} f=67×345136.f = \frac{67 \times 345}{136}.

Divide numerator and denominator by 17:

34517=20.294…and13617=8.\frac{345}{17} = 20.294\ldots \quad\text{and}\quad \frac{136}{17} = 8. So

f≈67×20.2948=1359.78≈169.96.f \approx \frac{67 \times 20.294}{8} = \frac{1359.7}{8} \approx 169.96.

Rounding to the nearest whole number gives

f≈170  Hz.f \approx 170\;{\rm Hz}.

Among the given options, this matches Option D.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Doppler effect in sound. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
ChapterWaves
TopicDoppler effect in sound
TypeMultiple choice