RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2017 · 08 APR ONLINE+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2017 Physics question — Second law, heat engines, refrigerators and reversibility

An engine operates by taking nn moles of an ideal gas through the cycle ABCDAABCDA shown in figure. The thermal efficiency of the engine is: (Take Cv=1.5RC_v = 1.5R, where RR is gas constant)

Figure for JEE Main 2017 Physics question on Second law, heat engines, refrigerators and reversibility
SOLUTION

Let us read the diagram (not to scale) as a rectangle in the P−VP{-}V plane whose corners are

A(P0,V0)A(P_0,V_0), B(2P0,V0)B(2P_0,V_0), C(2P0,2V0)C(2P_0,2V_0), D(P0,2V0)D(P_0,2V_0).

Thus

AB is an isochoric rise in pressure, BC is an isobaric expansion, CD is an isochoric fall in pressure and DA is an isobaric compression, finally returning to the initial state. The working substance is an ideal gas containing nn moles with Cv=1.5RC_v = 1.5R, so that Cp=Cv+R=2.5R.C_p = C_v + R = 2.5R. We now follow the gas round the cycle, calculating the work WW and the heat absorbed QinQ_{\text{in}} step by step.

State-variables at the four corners

The ideal-gas equation PV=nRTPV = nRT gives the temperatures

TA=P0V0nR,TB=2P0V0nR=2TA,TC=2P0 (2V0)nR=4TA,TD=P0 (2V0)nR=2TA.T_A = \frac{P_0 V_0}{nR},\qquad T_B = \frac{2P_0 V_0}{nR}=2T_A,\qquad T_C = \frac{2P_0\,(2V_0)}{nR}=4T_A,\qquad T_D = \frac{P_0\,(2V_0)}{nR}=2T_A.

Process AB  (isochoric, V=V0V=V_0)

Work done: WAB=0.W_{AB}=0.
Change in internal energy: ΔUAB=nCv (TB−TA)=nCv(2TA−TA)=nCvTA.\Delta U_{AB}=nC_v\,(T_B-T_A)=nC_v(2T_A-T_A)=nC_vT_A.
Heat absorbed: QAB=WAB+ΔUAB=nCvTA.Q_{AB}=W_{AB}+\Delta U_{AB}=nC_vT_A.

Process BC  (isobaric, P=2P0P=2P_0)

Work done: WBC=P (V2−V1)=2P0 (2V0−V0)=2P0V0.W_{BC}=P\,(V_2-V_1)=2P_0\,(2V_0-V_0)=2P_0V_0.
Convert the above work into a more useful form by replacing P0V0P_0V_0 with nRTAnRT_A obtained from TAT_A: WBC=2 nRTA.W_{BC}=2\,nRT_A.
Change in internal energy: ΔUBC=nCv (TC−TB)=nCv (4TA−2TA)=2nCvTA.\Delta U_{BC}=nC_v\,(T_C-T_B)=nC_v\,(4T_A-2T_A)=2nC_vT_A.
Heat absorbed: QBC=WBC+ΔUBC=2nRTA+2nCvTA=2n(Cv+R)TA=2nCpTA.Q_{BC}=W_{BC}+\Delta U_{BC}=2nRT_A+2nC_vT_A=2n(C_v+R)T_A=2nC_pT_A.

Process CD  (isochoric cooling)

This branch rejects heat, so its contribution is not counted in Qin.Q_{\text{in}}.

Process DA  (isobaric compression)

This branch also rejects heat and therefore does not enter Qin.Q_{\text{in}}.

Total heat absorbed during the cycle

Qin=QAB+QBC=nCvTA+2nCpTA=nTA (Cv+2Cp).Q_{\text{in}} = Q_{AB} + Q_{BC} = nC_vT_A + 2nC_pT_A = nT_A\,(C_v + 2C_p).
Insert the numerical values Cv=1.5R,  Cp=2.5RC_v = 1.5R,\; C_p = 2.5R: Qin=nTA [ 1.5R+2(2.5R) ]=nTA(1.5R+5R)=6.5 nRTA.Q_{\text{in}} = nT_A\,[\,1.5R + 2(2.5R)\,] = nT_A(1.5R + 5R)=6.5\,nRT_A.

Net work done per cycle

The work done is the area of the rectangle ABCDAABCDA:

W=(PC−PD) (VC−VB)=(2P0−P0) (2V0−V0)=P0V0.W = (P_C - P_D)\,(V_C - V_B) = (2P_0 - P_0)\,(2V_0 - V_0)=P_0V_0.
Replacing P0V0P_0V_0 by nRTAnRT_A again gives W=nRTA.W = nRT_A.

Thermal efficiency

The definition is η=WQin.\eta = \dfrac{W}{Q_{\text{in}}}. Substituting the expressions just obtained,

η=nRTA6.5 nRTA=16.5≈0.154≃0.15.\eta = \frac{nRT_A}{6.5\,nRT_A}= \frac1{6.5}\approx 0.154\simeq 0.15.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Second law, heat engines, refrigerators and reversibility. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicSecond law, heat engines, refrigerators and reversibility
TypeMultiple choice