RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 07 JAN S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Carnot engine and Carnot cycle

Two ideal Carnot engines operate in cascade (all heat given up by one engine is used by the other engine to produce work) between temperatures, T1_1 and T2_2. The temperature of the hot reservoir of the first engine is T1_1 and the temperature of the cold reservoir of the second engine is T2_2. T is temperature of the sink of first engine which is also the source for the second engine. How is T related to T1_1 and T2_2, if both the engines perform equal amount of work?

SOLUTION

First we recall the Carnot‐engine efficiency formula, valid for all temperatures measured on the absolute (kelvin) scale:

Efficiency=1−TcoldThot.\text{Efficiency} = 1 - \dfrac{T_\text{cold}}{T_\text{hot}}.

The first engine works between the hot reservoir at temperature T1T_1 and the intermediate reservoir at temperature TT. Its efficiency is therefore

η1=1−TT1.\eta_1 = 1 - \dfrac{T}{T_1}.

Let us denote by Q1Q_1 the heat absorbed from the hot reservoir T1T_1. The work produced by this first engine is

W1=η1Q1=(1−TT1)Q1.W_1 = \eta_1 Q_1 = \left(1 - \dfrac{T}{T_1}\right)Q_1.

The heat rejected by the first engine becomes the input heat for the second engine. Using the definition Qrejected=Qabsorbed−WQ_\text{rejected} = Q_\text{absorbed} - W we write

Qrejected,1=Q1−W1.Q_{\text{rejected},1} = Q_1 - W_1.

Substituting the value of W1W_1 we get

Qrejected,1=Q1−(1−TT1)Q1=Q1[1−1+TT1]=Q1TT1.Q_{\text{rejected},1} = Q_1 - \left(1 - \dfrac{T}{T_1}\right)Q_1 = Q_1 \left[1 - 1 + \dfrac{T}{T_1}\right] = Q_1 \dfrac{T}{T_1}.

This rejected heat is the heat absorbed by the second engine, so we set

Q2=Qrejected,1=Q1TT1.Q_2 = Q_{\text{rejected},1} = Q_1 \dfrac{T}{T_1}.

The second engine operates between the source at TT and the sink at T2T_2. Its efficiency is

η2=1−T2T.\eta_2 = 1 - \dfrac{T_2}{T}.

Hence the work done by the second engine is

W2=η2Q2=(1−T2T)(Q1TT1).W_2 = \eta_2 Q_2 = \left(1 - \dfrac{T_2}{T}\right) \left(Q_1 \dfrac{T}{T_1}\right).

We are told that both engines perform equal amounts of work, so we impose the condition

W1=W2.W_1 = W_2.

Substituting the expressions for W1W_1 and W2W_2, we have

(1−TT1)Q1=(1−T2T)(Q1TT1).\left(1 - \dfrac{T}{T_1}\right)Q_1 = \left(1 - \dfrac{T_2}{T}\right) \left(Q_1 \dfrac{T}{T_1}\right).

Dividing both sides by Q1Q_1 (which is non-zero) gives

1−TT1=(1−T2T)TT1.1 - \dfrac{T}{T_1} = \left(1 - \dfrac{T_2}{T}\right)\dfrac{T}{T_1}.

Now we multiply every term by T1T_1 to clear the denominators:

T1−T=(1−T2T)T.T_1 - T = \left(1 - \dfrac{T_2}{T}\right)T.

Expanding the right-hand side:

T1−T=T−T2TT.T_1 - T = T - \dfrac{T_2 T}{T}.

Simplifying the last term T2TT=T2\dfrac{T_2 T}{T} = T_2, we obtain

T1−T=T−T2.T_1 - T = T - T_2.

Bringing like terms together:

T1+T2=2T.T_1 + T_2 = 2T.

Finally we solve for the intermediate temperature TT:

T=T1+T22.T = \dfrac{T_1 + T_2}{2}.

Thus the required temperature is simply the arithmetic mean of T1T_1 and T2T_2.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Carnot engine and Carnot cycle. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicCarnot engine and Carnot cycle
TypeMultiple choice