RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 05 SEP S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Work done in thermodynamic processes and P-V diagrams

Three different processes that can occur in an ideal monoatomic gas are shown in the PP vs VV diagram. The paths are labelled as A→BA \to B, A→CA \to C and A→DA \to D. The change in internal energies during these processes are taken as EABE_{AB}, EACE_{AC} and EADE_{AD} and the work done as WABW_{AB}, WACW_{AC} and WADW_{AD}. The correct relation between these parameters are:

Figure for JEE Main 2020 Physics question on Work done in thermodynamic processes and P-V diagrams
SOLUTION

We are dealing with an ideal mono-atomic gas. For such a gas the internal energy is a pure function of temperature alone and is given by the well-known expression

U=32 nRT.U=\tfrac32\,nRT.

Consequently, the change in internal energy between any two states depends only on the initial and final temperatures:

ΔU=32 nR (Tfinal−Tinitial).\Delta U=\tfrac32\,nR\,(T_{\text{final}}-T_{\text{initial}}).

In the P ⁣− ⁣VP\!-\!V diagram all three processes start from the common state A(PA,VA,TA)A(P_A,V_A,T_A) and terminate at the three distinct points B,  C,  DB,\;C,\;D. A careful inspection of the diagram shows that the points B,  C,  DB,\;C,\;D lie on the same isothermal curve that passes through none of the other points. Algebraically that statement reads

PBVB=PCVC=PDVD=k(constant).P_BV_B=P_CV_C=P_DV_D=k\quad(\text{constant}).

Using the ideal-gas equation PV=nRTPV=nRT this instantly gives

TB=TC=TD=T′,T_B=T_C=T_D=T',

where T′T' is some temperature (which may or may not equal TAT_A). Because all three final temperatures are equal, the change in internal energy from the common initial state AA to any of the three final states is identical:

EAB=ΔUAB=32 nR (T′−TA),E_{AB}=\Delta U_{AB}=\tfrac32\,nR\,(T'-T_A),

EAC=ΔUAC=32 nR (T′−TA),E_{AC}=\Delta U_{AC}=\tfrac32\,nR\,(T'-T_A),

EAD=ΔUAD=32 nR (T′−TA).E_{AD}=\Delta U_{AD}=\tfrac32\,nR\,(T'-T_A).

Hence

EAB=EAC=EAD.E_{AB}=E_{AC}=E_{AD}.

Next we examine the work done, remembering the definition

W=∫VinitialVfinalP dV.W=\int_{V_{\text{initial}}}^{V_{\text{final}}}P\,dV.

Sign conventions to keep in mind:

• When the gas expands, dV>0dV>0 so W>0W>0(positive work done by the gas).
• When the gas undergoes an isochoric (constant-volume) change, dV=0dV=0 so W=0W=0(no work).
• When the gas is compressed, dV<0dV<0 so W<0W<0(negative work, work done on the gas).

Looking again at the geometry of the three paths:

• Along A→BA\to B the curve clearly moves to a larger volume: VB>VAV_B>V_A. Therefore W_{AB}>0.$</p> <p>• AlongA\to Cthepathisvertical,i.e.thevolumeisunchanged:the path is vertical, i.e. the volume is unchanged:V_C=V_A.Hence. HenceW_{AC}=0.$

• Along A→DA\to D the path proceeds to a smaller volume: VD<VAV_D<V_A. Consequently W_{AD}<0.$</p> <p>Collecting all the deductions we have</p> <p>E_{AB}=E_{AC}=E_{AD},\qquad W_{AB}>0,\qquad W_{AC}=0,\qquad W_{AD}<0.$$

This set of equalities and inequalities is exactly the one listed in Option B of the question.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Work done in thermodynamic processes and P-V diagrams. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicWork done in thermodynamic processes and P-V diagrams
TypeMultiple choice