RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 27 JUL S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Physics question — Carnot engine and Carnot cycle

Two Carnot engines AA and BB operate in series such that engine A absorbs heat at T1T_1 and rejects heat to a sink at temperature T. Engine B absorbs half of the heat rejected by Engine AA and rejects heat to the sink at T3T_3. When workdone in both the cases is equal, to value of T is:

SOLUTION

For every Carnot engine the efficiency is given by the well-known relation

η=1−TcoldThot.\eta = 1-\dfrac{T_{\text{cold}}}{T_{\text{hot}}}.

Engine A works between the temperatures T1T_1 (source) and TT (sink). Let the heat absorbed from the hot reservoir be Q1Q_1. Using the above formula we have for engine A

ηA=1−TT1.\eta_A = 1-\dfrac{T}{T_1}.

Therefore the work obtained from engine A is

WA=ηAQ1=(1−TT1)Q1.W_A=\eta_A Q_1=\Bigl(1-\dfrac{T}{T_1}\Bigr)Q_1.

The heat rejected by engine A to the intermediate reservoir at temperature TT is found from the first law:

Q2=Q1−WA</p><p>=Q1−(1−TT1)Q1</p><p>=Q1TT1.Q_2 = Q_1-W_A</p> <p> = Q_1 -\Bigl(1-\dfrac{T}{T_1}\Bigr)Q_1</p> <p> = Q_1\dfrac{T}{T_1}.

According to the statement of the problem, engine B absorbs only half of this rejected heat, so

QB=Q22=Q1T2T1.Q_B = \dfrac{Q_2}{2}= \dfrac{Q_1 T}{2T_1}.

Engine B now works between the temperatures TT (source) and T3T_3 (sink). Its Carnot efficiency is

ηB=1−T3T.\eta_B = 1-\dfrac{T_3}{T}.

Hence the work obtained from engine B is

WB=ηBQB</p><p>=(1−T3T)Q1T2T1.W_B = \eta_B Q_B</p> <p> =\Bigl(1-\dfrac{T_3}{T}\Bigr)\dfrac{Q_1 T}{2T_1}.

The condition given is that both engines produce the same work, i.e.

WA=WB.W_A = W_B.

Substituting the expressions for WAW_A and WBW_B we get

(1−TT1)Q1</p><p>=(1−T3T)Q1T2T1.\Bigl(1-\dfrac{T}{T_1}\Bigr)Q_1</p> <p> =\Bigl(1-\dfrac{T_3}{T}\Bigr)\dfrac{Q_1 T}{2T_1}.

The factor Q1Q_1 is present on both sides, so it cancels out. Multiplying the remaining equation by 2T12T_1 we obtain

2T1(1−TT1)=T(1−T3T).2T_1\Bigl(1-\dfrac{T}{T_1}\Bigr)=T\Bigl(1-\dfrac{T_3}{T}\Bigr).

Rewriting the terms inside the brackets gives

2T1(T1−TT1)=T(T−T3T).2T_1\Bigl(\dfrac{T_1-T}{T_1}\Bigr)=T\Bigl(\dfrac{T-T_3}{T}\Bigr).

Simplifying each side separately:

2(T1−T)=T−T3.2(T_1-T)=T-T_3.

Expanding and collecting the temperature terms leads to

2T1−2T=T−T3.2T_1-2T = T - T_3.

Now shift all terms involving TT to one side and the constants to the other:

2T1+T3=3T.2T_1 + T_3 = 3T.

Finally, solving for the unknown intermediate temperature TT yields

T=2T1+T33</p><p>=23T1+13T3.T = \dfrac{2T_1+T_3}{3}</p> <p> = \dfrac{2}{3}T_1 + \dfrac{1}{3}T_3.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Carnot engine and Carnot cycle. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicCarnot engine and Carnot cycle
TypeMultiple choice