RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 25 JUL S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Physics question — Carnot engine and Carnot cycle

A heat engine has an efficiency of 16\frac{1}{6}. When the temperature of sink is reduced by 62°C, its efficiency gets doubled. The temperature of the source is:

SOLUTION

Let us denote the temperature of the hot reservoir (source) by T1T_1 and that of the cold reservoir (sink) by T2T_2. Throughout the calculation all temperatures will be expressed on the absolute (kelvin) scale; a change of 1 °C equals a change of 1 K, so differences can be handled in either unit without confusion.

For an ideal (Carnot) heat engine, the efficiency η\eta is given by the well-known relation

η  =  1−T2T1.\eta \;=\;1-\dfrac{T_2}{T_1}.

We are first told that the efficiency is 16\dfrac16. Substituting this value into the formula we have

1−T2T1  =  16.1-\dfrac{T_2}{T_1}\;=\;\dfrac16.

Rearranging term by term,

T2T1  =  1−16  =  56,\dfrac{T_2}{T_1}\;=\;1-\dfrac16\;=\;\dfrac56,

and hence

T2=56 T1.−(1)T_2=\dfrac56\,T_1. \quad -(1)

Next, the problem states that the sink temperature is lowered by 62 °C (that is, by 62 K). Let the new sink temperature be T2′T_2'. Then

T2′=T2−62.T_2' = T_2 - 62.

With this altered sink temperature the efficiency doubles, becoming 2×16=132\times\dfrac16=\dfrac13. Applying the efficiency formula once more, we get

1−T2′T1  =  13.1-\dfrac{T_2'}{T_1}\;=\;\dfrac13.

Solving for the ratio,

T2′T1  =  1−13  =  23,\dfrac{T_2'}{T_1}\;=\;1-\dfrac13\;=\;\dfrac23,

so

T2′=23 T1.−(2)T_2'=\dfrac23\,T_1. \quad -(2)

Now we substitute T2=56 T1T_2=\dfrac56\,T_1 from equation (1) into the definition of T2′T_2':

T2′=T2−62  =  56 T1  −  62.T_2' = T_2 - 62 \;=\;\dfrac56\,T_1\;-\;62.

But equation (2) tells us that T2′=23 T1T_2'=\dfrac23\,T_1. Equating the two expressions for T2′T_2' gives

56 T1  −  62  =  23 T1.\dfrac56\,T_1\;-\;62 \;=\;\dfrac23\,T_1.

To collect like terms, we bring the right-hand term to the left:

56 T1−23 T1  =  62.\dfrac56\,T_1 - \dfrac23\,T_1 \;=\;62.

Writing both fractions with a common denominator 6, 23 T1=46 T1\dfrac23\,T_1=\dfrac46\,T_1, so

(56−46)T1  =  62.\left(\dfrac56 - \dfrac46\right)T_1 \;=\;62.

The difference in the parentheses is 16\dfrac16, hence

16 T1  =  62.\dfrac16\,T_1 \;=\;62.

Multiplying both sides by 6 we arrive at

T1  =  372  K.T_1 \;=\;372\;\text{K}.

Finally, converting back to the Celsius scale (recall T(°C)=T(K)−273T(\text{°C}) = T(\text{K}) - 273), we obtain

T1=372  K−273=99  ∘C.T_1 = 372\;\text{K} - 273 = 99\;^\circ\text{C}.

Hence, the correct answer is Option D.

Tagged Carnot engine and Carnot cycle. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicCarnot engine and Carnot cycle
TypeMultiple choice