RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 10 JAN S1+4 / −1HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Physics question — Carnot engine and Carnot cycle

Three Carnot engines operate in series between a heat source at a temperature T1T_1 and a heat sink at temperature T4T_4 (see figure). There are two other reservoirs at temperature T2T_2 and T3T_3, as shown, with T1>T2>T3>T4T_1 > T_2 > T_3 > T_4. The three engines are equally efficient if:

Figure for JEE Main 2019 Physics question on Carnot engine and Carnot cycle
SOLUTION

We are given three Carnot engines working one after the other (in series). The temperatures of the four reservoirs, arranged from hottest to coldest, are T1, T2, T3,T_1, T_2, T_3, and T4T_4 with T1>T2>T3>T4.T_1 > T_2 > T_3 > T_4.

For any Carnot engine operating between a hot reservoir at temperature ThT_h and a cold reservoir at Tc,T_c, the thermal efficiency is, by definition,

η=1−TcTh.\eta = 1-\dfrac{T_c}{T_h}.

Because the engines are in series, the first engine works between T1T_1 (hot) and T2T_2 (cold), the second between T2T_2 and T3,T_3, and the third between T3T_3 and T4.T_4. Their efficiencies are therefore

η1=1−T2T1,η2=1−T3T2,η3=1−T4T3.\eta_1 = 1-\dfrac{T_2}{T_1}, \qquad \eta_2 = 1-\dfrac{T_3}{T_2}, \qquad \eta_3 = 1-\dfrac{T_4}{T_3}.

The statement “the three engines are equally efficient’’ means

η1=η2=η3.\eta_1 = \eta_2 = \eta_3.

We first equate η1\eta_1 and η2.\eta_2. Starting with the equality

1−T2T1=1−T3T2,1-\dfrac{T_2}{T_1} = 1-\dfrac{T_3}{T_2},

we cancel the 1’s on both sides, giving

−T2T1=−T3T2.-\dfrac{T_2}{T_1} = -\dfrac{T_3}{T_2}.

Multiplying through by −1-1 to remove the negative sign, we have

T2T1=T3T2.\dfrac{T_2}{T_1} = \dfrac{T_3}{T_2}.

Cross-multiplication now yields

T22=T1 T3,T_2^2 = T_1\,T_3,

and solving for T3T_3 gives

T3=T22T1.−(1)T_3 = \dfrac{T_2^2}{T_1}. \quad -(1)

Next we equate η2\eta_2 and η3.\eta_3. Setting

1−T3T2=1−T4T3,1-\dfrac{T_3}{T_2} = 1-\dfrac{T_4}{T_3},

we again cancel the 1’s, obtaining

−T3T2=−T4T3.-\dfrac{T_3}{T_2} = -\dfrac{T_4}{T_3}.

After multiplying by −1,-1, we have

T3T2=T4T3,\dfrac{T_3}{T_2} = \dfrac{T_4}{T_3},

which upon cross-multiplication gives

T32=T2 T4.T_3^2 = T_2\,T_4.

Solving this for T2T_2 produces

T2=T32T4.−(2)T_2 = \dfrac{T_3^2}{T_4}. \quad -(2)

We now substitute the value of T3T_3 from equation (1) into equation (2). From (1) we have T3=T22T1,T_3 = \dfrac{T_2^2}{T_1}, so its square is

T32=(T22T1)2=T24T12.T_3^2 = \left(\dfrac{T_2^2}{T_1}\right)^2 = \dfrac{T_2^4}{T_1^2}.

Putting this into (2), we get

T2=T24T12T4.T_2 = \dfrac{\dfrac{T_2^4}{T_1^2}}{T_4}.

Simplifying the right-hand side gives

T2=T24T12 T4.T_2 = \dfrac{T_2^4}{T_1^2\,T_4}.

To isolate T2,T_2, we multiply both sides by T12 T4:T_1^2\,T_4:

(T12 T4) T2=T24.(T_1^2\,T_4)\,T_2 = T_2^4.

Dividing both sides by T2T_2 (which is positive by definition of temperature) yields

T12 T4=T23.T_1^2\,T_4 = T_2^3.

Taking the cube root of both sides, we arrive at

T2=(T12 T4)1/3.T_2 = (T_1^2\,T_4)^{1/3}.

With T2T_2 now known, we substitute back into equation (1) to find T3:T_3:

T3=T22T1=((T12 T4)1/3)2T1.T_3 = \dfrac{T_2^2}{T_1} = \dfrac{\left((T_1^2\,T_4)^{1/3}\right)^2}{T_1}.

Because ((T12 T4)1/3)2=(T12 T4)2/3,\left((T_1^2\,T_4)^{1/3}\right)^2 = (T_1^2\,T_4)^{2/3}, we have

T3=(T12 T4)2/3T1.T_3 = \dfrac{(T_1^2\,T_4)^{2/3}}{T_1}.

Splitting the power inside the numerator, (T12 T4)2/3=T14/3 T42/3,(T_1^2\,T_4)^{2/3} = T_1^{4/3}\,T_4^{2/3}, so

T3=T14/3 T42/3T1=T14/3−1 T42/3=T11/3 T42/3.T_3 = \dfrac{T_1^{4/3}\,T_4^{2/3}}{T_1} = T_1^{4/3 - 1}\,T_4^{2/3} = T_1^{1/3}\,T_4^{2/3}.

Writing this in compact radical form, we recognize

T3=(T1 T42)1/3.T_3 = (T_1\,T_4^2)^{1/3}.

We have therefore obtained

T2=(T12 T4)1/3,T3=(T1 T42)1/3.T_2 = (T_1^2\,T_4)^{1/3}, \qquad T_3 = (T_1\,T_4^2)^{1/3}.

Scanning the given answer choices, we see that these values correspond exactly to Option C.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Carnot engine and Carnot cycle. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicCarnot engine and Carnot cycle
TypeMultiple choice