RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 09 APR S1+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Physics question — Rolling with friction, slipping and impulsive forces

The following bodies are made to roll up (without slipping) the same inclined plane from a horizontal plane: (i) a ring of radius R, (ii) a solid cylinder of radius R2\frac{R}{2} and (iii) a solid sphere of radius R4\frac{R}{4}. If, in each case, the speed of the center of mass at the bottom of the incline is same, the ratio of the maximum heights they climb is:

SOLUTION

We have three different rigid bodies that roll without slipping and all start the climb with the same linear speed vv of their centres of mass at the foot of the incline. While climbing, every joule of the initial kinetic energy changes into gravitational potential energy until the bodies momentarily come to rest at their respective highest points. Hence we can write, for any one of them,

Initial kinetic energy=Gain in potential energy.\text{Initial kinetic energy}= \text{Gain in potential energy}.

The total kinetic energy of a rolling body is the sum of its translational part and its rotational part. Stating the formula first,

Ktotal=12 m v2  +  12 I ω2,K_{\text{total}}=\frac12\,m\,v^{2}\;+\;\frac12\,I\,\omega^{2},

where mm is the mass, II is the moment of inertia about its own axis, vv is the linear speed of the centre of mass and ω\omega is the angular speed. For rolling without slipping the well-known kinematic relation

v=ω rv=\omega\,r

holds, rr being the radius of the body that is in contact with the plane.

At the highest point the linear speed becomes zero, so the entire kinetic energy converts into gravitational potential energy mghmgh. Thus we write

mgh=12 m v2  +  12 I ω2.mgh=\frac12\,m\,v^{2}\;+\;\frac12\,I\,\omega^{2}.

Substituting ω=vr\omega=\dfrac{v}{r} gives

mgh=12 m v2+12 I(vr)2=v22[m+Ir2].mgh=\frac12\,m\,v^{2}+\frac12\,I\left(\frac{v}{r}\right)^{2}=\frac{v^{2}}{2}\left[m+\frac{I}{r^{2}}\right].

Dividing both sides by mgmg we arrive at the general expression for the maximum height climbed:

h=v22g[1+Im r2].h=\frac{v^{2}}{2g}\left[1+\frac{I}{m\,r^{2}}\right].

The factor Im r2\dfrac{I}{m\,r^{2}} is specific to the shape of the body but, importantly, does not depend on the numerical value of the radius itself. We now evaluate this factor for each body.

For the ring (radius RR) we know the standard moment of inertia Iring=m r2.I_{\text{ring}}=m\,r^{2}. Hence

Im r2=m r2m r2=1,\frac{I}{m\,r^{2}}=\frac{m\,r^{2}}{m\,r^{2}}=1,

so that

hring=v22g(1+1)=v22g×2.h_{\text{ring}}=\frac{v^{2}}{2g}\left(1+1\right)=\frac{v^{2}}{2g}\times2.

For the solid cylinder (radius R2\dfrac{R}{2}) the standard moment of inertia is Icyl=12 m r2.I_{\text{cyl}}=\dfrac12\,m\,r^{2}. Therefore

Im r2=12 m r2m r2=12,\frac{I}{m\,r^{2}}=\frac{\dfrac12\,m\,r^{2}}{m\,r^{2}}=\frac12,

and

hcyl=v22g(1+12)=v22g×32.h_{\text{cyl}}=\frac{v^{2}}{2g}\left(1+\frac12\right)=\frac{v^{2}}{2g}\times\frac32.

For the solid sphere (radius R4\dfrac{R}{4}) the standard moment of inertia is Isphere=25 m r2.I_{\text{sphere}}=\dfrac25\,m\,r^{2}. Thus

Im r2=25 m r2m r2=25,\frac{I}{m\,r^{2}}=\frac{\dfrac25\,m\,r^{2}}{m\,r^{2}}=\frac25,

and

hsphere=v22g(1+25)=v22g×75.h_{\text{sphere}}=\frac{v^{2}}{2g}\left(1+\frac25\right)=\frac{v^{2}}{2g}\times\frac75.

We now compare the three heights. The common prefactor v22g\dfrac{v^{2}}{2g} is the same for every body, so the ratio of maximum heights is governed solely by the parenthetic factors:

hring:hcyl:hsphere=2:32:75.h_{\text{ring}}:h_{\text{cyl}}:h_{\text{sphere}}=2:\frac32:\frac75.

To clear the fractions, multiply each term by 1010:

2×10=20,32×10=15,75×10=14.2\times10=20,\qquad\frac32\times10=15,\qquad\frac75\times10=14.

Therefore

hring:hcyl:hsphere=20:15:14.h_{\text{ring}}:h_{\text{cyl}}:h_{\text{sphere}}=20:15:14.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Rolling with friction, slipping and impulsive forces. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicRolling with friction, slipping and impulsive forces
TypeMultiple choice