RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 27 AUG S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Physics question — Angular momentum of particles and rigid bodies

Two discs have moments of inertia I1I_1 and I2I_2 about their respective axes perpendicular to the plane and passing through the centre. They are rotating with angular speeds, ω1\omega_1 and ω2\omega_2 respectively and are brought into contact face to face with their axes of rotation coaxial. The loss in kinetic energy of the system in the process is given by:

SOLUTION

The two discs are coupled coaxially, so no external torque acts about the common axis. Therefore, by the principle of conservation of angular momentum, the total angular momentum before contact equals the angular momentum after the discs have come to a common angular speed.

Initially, disc 1 has angular momentum I1ω1I_1\omega_1 and disc 2 has angular momentum I2ω2I_2\omega_2. Hence the total initial angular momentum is Linitial  =  I1ω1  +  I2ω2.L_{\text{initial}} \;=\; I_1\omega_1 \;+\; I_2\omega_2. After they come in contact and rotate together, let the common angular speed be ωf\omega_f. The combined moment of inertia is I1+I2,I_1+I_2, so the final angular momentum is Lfinal  =  (I1+I2) ωf.L_{\text{final}} \;=\; (I_1+I_2)\,\omega_f. Setting Linitial=LfinalL_{\text{initial}}=L_{\text{final}} we have (I1+I2) ωf  =  I1ω1+I2ω2.(I_1+I_2)\,\omega_f \;=\; I_1\omega_1 + I_2\omega_2. Now solving for the common angular speed, ωf  =  I1ω1+I2ω2I1+I2.\omega_f \;=\; \dfrac{I_1\omega_1 + I_2\omega_2}{I_1+I_2}.

The kinetic energy of rotation is given by the formula K  =  12Iω2.K \;=\; \tfrac12 I\omega^2. Using this, the initial kinetic energy of the system is Kinitial  =  12I1ω1 2  +  12I2ω2 2.K_{\text{initial}} \;=\; \tfrac12 I_1\omega_1^{\,2} \;+\; \tfrac12 I_2\omega_2^{\,2}. The final kinetic energy, when both discs rotate together with angular speed ωf,\omega_f, is Kfinal  =  12(I1+I2) ωf 2.K_{\text{final}} \;=\; \tfrac12 (I_1+I_2)\,\omega_f^{\,2}.

We substitute the value of ωf\omega_f obtained earlier: Kfinal  =  12(I1+I2)(I1ω1+I2ω2I1+I2) ⁣2  =  12(I1ω1+I2ω2)2I1+I2.K_{\text{final}} \;=\; \tfrac12 (I_1+I_2) \left( \dfrac{I_1\omega_1 + I_2\omega_2}{I_1+I_2} \right)^{\!2} \;=\; \tfrac12 \dfrac{(I_1\omega_1 + I_2\omega_2)^{2}}{I_1+I_2}.

The loss in kinetic energy is the difference between the initial and final values: ΔK  =  Kinitial−Kfinal  =  12I1ω1 2+12I2ω2 2  −  12(I1ω1+I2ω2)2I1+I2.\Delta K \;=\; K_{\text{initial}} - K_{\text{final}} \;=\; \tfrac12 I_1\omega_1^{\,2} + \tfrac12 I_2\omega_2^{\,2} \;-\; \tfrac12 \dfrac{(I_1\omega_1 + I_2\omega_2)^{2}}{I_1+I_2}.

For easier algebra, we factor out 12\tfrac12 and bring everything over the common denominator I1+I2I_1+I_2: ΔK  =  12 (I1+I2)(I1ω1 2+I2ω2 2)−(I1ω1+I2ω2)2 I1+I2 .\Delta K \;=\; \tfrac12\, \dfrac{(I_1+I_2)(I_1\omega_1^{\,2} + I_2\omega_2^{\,2}) - (I_1\omega_1 + I_2\omega_2)^{2}} {\,I_1+I_2\,}. Now we expand the numerator term by term.

First expand the product: (I1+I2)(I1ω1 2+I2ω2 2) = I12ω1 2  +  I1I2ω2 2  +  I1I2ω1 2  +  I22ω2 2.(I_1+I_2)(I_1\omega_1^{\,2} + I_2\omega_2^{\,2}) \,=\, I_1^{2}\omega_1^{\,2} \;+\; I_1I_2\omega_2^{\,2} \;+\; I_1I_2\omega_1^{\,2} \;+\; I_2^{2}\omega_2^{\,2}. Next expand the square: (I1ω1+I2ω2)2 = I12ω1 2  +  I22ω2 2  +  2I1I2ω1ω2.(I_1\omega_1 + I_2\omega_2)^{2} \,=\, I_1^{2}\omega_1^{\,2} \;+\; I_2^{2}\omega_2^{\,2} \;+\; 2I_1I_2\omega_1\omega_2. Substituting these back into the numerator gives [I12ω1 2+I1I2ω2 2+I1I2ω1 2+I22ω2 2]  −  [I12ω1 2+I22ω2 2+2I1I2ω1ω2].\bigl[I_1^{2}\omega_1^{\,2}+I_1I_2\omega_2^{\,2}+I_1I_2\omega_1^{\,2}+I_2^{2}\omega_2^{\,2}\bigr] \;-\; \bigl[I_1^{2}\omega_1^{\,2}+I_2^{2}\omega_2^{\,2}+2I_1I_2\omega_1\omega_2\bigr].$

Now we cancel identical terms and collect the remaining ones: I12ω1 2 and I22ω2 2I_1^{2}\omega_1^{\,2} \text{ and } I_2^{2}\omega_2^{\,2} appear in both brackets and therefore cancel out. What is left is I1I2ω2 2+I1I2ω1 2−2I1I2ω1ω2  =  I1I2(ω1 2−2ω1ω2+ω2 2)  =  I1I2(ω1−ω2)2.I_1I_2\omega_2^{\,2} + I_1I_2\omega_1^{\,2} - 2I_1I_2\omega_1\omega_2 \;=\; I_1I_2\bigl(\omega_1^{\,2} - 2\omega_1\omega_2 + \omega_2^{\,2}\bigr) \;=\; I_1I_2(\omega_1 - \omega_2)^{2}. Hence the numerator simplifies neatly to I1I2(ω1−ω2)2.I_1I_2(\omega_1 - \omega_2)^{2}.

Putting this back, we obtain ΔK  =  12 I1I2(ω1−ω2)2I1+I2.\Delta K \;=\; \tfrac12\, \dfrac{I_1I_2(\omega_1 - \omega_2)^{2}}{I_1 + I_2}. Thus the loss in kinetic energy is ΔK  =  I1I22 (I1+I2) (ω1−ω2)2.\Delta K \;=\; \frac{I_1I_2}{2\,(I_1+I_2)}\,(\omega_1 - \omega_2)^{2}.

Comparing with the options, this matches Option C.

Hence, the correct answer is Option C.

Tagged Angular momentum of particles and rigid bodies. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicAngular momentum of particles and rigid bodies
TypeMultiple choice