RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2021 · 25 JUL S1+4 / −1EASYTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2021 Physics question — Moment of inertia of standard bodies and composite systems

Given below are two statements: one is labelled as Assertion A and the other is labelled as Reason R.
Assertion A: Moment of inertia of a circular disc of mass M and radius R about X, Y axes (passing through its plane) and Z-axis which is perpendicular to its plane were found to be IxI_x, IyI_y and IzI_z, respectively. The respective radii of gyration about all the three axes will be the same.
Reason R: A rigid body making rotational motion has fixed mass and shape. In the light of the above statements, choose the most appropriate answer from the options given below:

SOLUTION

We begin by recalling the definition of moment of inertia. For any rigid body about a given axis we write the relation

I=M k2I = M\,k^{2}

where II is the moment of inertia, MM is the total mass of the body, and kk is the radius of gyration about that axis. The radius of gyration therefore depends directly on the numerical value of the moment of inertia about the chosen axis.

Now we consider a uniform thin circular disc of mass MM and radius RR. Its centre is the origin, its plane is the X-Y plane, so the Z-axis passes through its centre perpendicular to the plane. The X- and Y-axes are two mutually perpendicular diameters lying in the plane of the disc.

First, we write down the standard results for the moments of inertia of such a disc (these results can be obtained by integration, but are quoted here as standard):

IZ=12 MR2(about the Z-axis)I_{Z} = \frac12\,M R^{2} \qquad\text{(about the Z-axis)}$

IX=IY=14 MR2(about any diameter in the plane, e.g. X or Y axis)I_{X} = I_{Y} = \frac14\,M R^{2} \qquad\text{(about any diameter in the plane, e.g. X or Y axis)}$

We next find the radii of gyration corresponding to each axis by substituting these values into the defining equation I=M k2I = M\,k^{2}.

For the Z-axis we have

kZ2=IZM=12 MR2M=12 R2k_{Z}^{2} = \frac{I_{Z}}{M} = \frac{\dfrac12\,M R^{2}}{M} = \frac12\,R^{2}$

so

kZ=12 R=R2 .k_{Z} = \sqrt{\frac12}\,R = \frac{R}{\sqrt2}\,.

For the X-axis we write

kX2=IXM=14 MR2M=14 R2k_{X}^{2} = \frac{I_{X}}{M} = \frac{\dfrac14\,M R^{2}}{M} = \frac14\,R^{2}$

and therefore

kX=14 R=R2 .k_{X} = \sqrt{\frac14}\,R = \frac{R}{2}\,.

The Y-axis expression is identical because IY=IXI_{Y} = I_{X}, giving

kY=R2 .k_{Y} = \frac{R}{2}\,.

So we finally have

kX=kY=R2,kZ=R2 .k_{X} = k_{Y} = \frac{R}{2}, \qquad k_{Z} = \frac{R}{\sqrt2}\,.

These three values are clearly not equal because

R2≠R2 .\frac{R}{2} \neq \frac{R}{\sqrt2}\,.

Therefore the assertion “the respective radii of gyration about all the three axes will be the same” is false.

We now examine the reason. The statement “A rigid body making rotational motion has fixed mass and shape” is always true; the mass and the geometrical size of a rigid body do not change during rotation. Hence the reason is a correct factual statement, although it has no logical connection with the equality (or inequality) of the radii of gyration.

We thus have: Assertion A is not correct, while Reason R is correct but does not explain A.

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Moment of inertia of standard bodies and composite systems. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicMoment of inertia of standard bodies and composite systems
TypeMultiple choice