RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2012TRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2012 Physics question — Conservation of angular momentum

This question has Statement 1 and Statement 2. Out of the four choices given after the Statements, choose the one that best describes the two Statements.

Statement 1: When moment of inertia II of a body rotating about an axis with angular speed ω\omega increases, its angular momentum LL is unchanged but the kinetic energy KK increases if there is no torque applied on it. 

Statement 2: L=IωL = I\omega, kinetic energy of rotation =12Iω2= \dfrac{1}{2}I\omega^2

SOLUTION

For a rigid body rotating about a fixed axis, the two standard relations are
angular momentum L=IωL = I\omega and rotational kinetic energy K=12Iω2K = \dfrac{1}{2}I\omega^{2}.
These are quoted in Statement 2.

Checking Statement 1
Suppose no external torque acts on the system. Then total angular momentum about that axis is conserved:

L=constantL = \text{constant}

If during the motion the moment of inertia changes from I1I_1 to I2I_2 (for example, by redistributing the mass), conservation gives

I1ω1=I2ω2⇒ω2=I1I2 ω1I_1\omega_1 = I_2\omega_2 \quad\Rightarrow\quad \omega_2 = \frac{I_1}{I_2}\,\omega_1

Rotational kinetic energy after the change will be

K2=12I2ω22=12I2(I1I2ω1)2=12I12I2 ω12K_2 = \tfrac12 I_2\omega_2^{2} = \tfrac12 I_2\left(\frac{I_1}{I_2}\omega_1\right)^{2} = \tfrac12\frac{I_1^{2}}{I_2}\,\omega_1^{2}

Since I2>I1I_2 \gt I_1 by assumption (moment of inertia increases), the factor I12I2\frac{I_1^{2}}{I_2} is < I1 I_1\,, so

K2<12I1ω12=K1K_2 \lt \tfrac12 I_1\omega_1^{2}=K_1

Thus the kinetic energy decreases when II increases at constant external torque (zero torque).

Statement 1 claims that kinetic energy increases, which is opposite to what we have derived. Therefore Statement 1 is false.

Checking Statement 2
Statement 2 merely quotes the standard relations L=IωL = I\omega and K=12Iω2K = \tfrac12 I\omega^{2}. These formulas are correct, so Statement 2 is true.

We therefore have:
Statement 1 - false;  Statement 2 - true.

Option B which states “Statement 1 is false, Statement 2 is true” is the correct choice.

Tagged Conservation of angular momentum. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicConservation of angular momentum
TypeMultiple choice