RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 12 APR S1+4 / −1HARDTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Physics question — Angular momentum of particles and rigid bodies

A person of mass M is sitting on a swing of length L and swinging with an angular amplitude θ0\theta_0. If the person stands up when the swing passes through its lowest point, the work done by him, assuming that his centre of mass moves by a distance ll (l<<Ll << L), is close to:

SOLUTION

We treat the man-swing system as a simple pendulum whose bob (the person’s centre of mass while he is sitting) is at a distance LL from the pivot. The swing is released from an angular amplitude θ0\theta_0 and reaches the lowest position (the vertical) with a certain speed. Exactly at this lowest point the person suddenly stands up, raising his centre of mass vertically by a small amount ll (l≪Ll \ll L). We have to calculate the work that the person must do in order to achieve this rise and the accompanying change in kinetic energy of the swing.

First, let us find the speed just before the person stands up. Using mechanical-energy conservation for a pendulum of length LL:

Initial potential energy (at amplitude θ0\theta_0) relative to the lowest point is

Ui  =  MgL(1−cos⁡θ0).U_i \;=\; MgL\bigl(1-\cos\theta_0\bigr).

At the lowest point this potential energy has completely converted into kinetic energy, so

12Mv12  =  MgL(1−cos⁡θ0).\tfrac12 Mv_1^2 \;=\; MgL\bigl(1-\cos\theta_0\bigr).

Therefore the linear speed just before standing up is

v1  =   2gL(1−cos⁡θ0).v_1 \;=\; \sqrt{\,2gL\bigl(1-\cos\theta_0\bigr)}.

Now the person suddenly reduces the radius of circular motion from LL to

R2  =  L−l,R_2 \;=\; L-l,

because his centre of mass rises by ll. The interval in which he stands is taken to be very short, so the external torque about the pivot is practically zero (gravity acts along the vertical line through the pivot at that instant), and angular momentum about the pivot is conserved.

The angular momentum just before standing is

Lang,1  =  Mv1L.L_{\text{ang},1} \;=\; Mv_1 L.

Let the new speed immediately after standing be v2v_2. Conservation of angular momentum gives

Mv1L  =  Mv2(L−l)Mv_1L \;=\; Mv_2\bigl(L-l\bigr)

⟹  v2  =  v1 LL−l.\Longrightarrow\; v_2 \;=\; v_1\,\frac{L}{L-l}.

Hence the new kinetic energy is

K2=12Mv22=12Mv12(LL−l)2.K_2 = \tfrac12 Mv_2^2 = \tfrac12 Mv_1^2 \left(\frac{L}{L-l}\right)^2.

The potential energy has also increased, because the centre of mass is now higher by ll. The increase in gravitational potential energy is

ΔU  =  Mg l.\Delta U \;=\; Mg\,l.

The work done by the person equals the total increase in mechanical energy, i.e.

W  =  (K2+U2)−(K1+U1)  =  (K2−K1)+ΔU.W \;=\; (K_2 + U_2) - (K_1 + U_1) \;=\; (K_2 - K_1) + \Delta U.

Let us compute the kinetic-energy change:

K2−K1=12Mv12 ⁣[(LL−l)2−1].K_2 - K_1 = \tfrac12 Mv_1^2\!\left[\left(\frac{L}{L-l}\right)^2 - 1\right].

Because l≪Ll\ll L, we introduce the small parameter

ε  =  lL,with ε≪1.\varepsilon \;=\; \frac{l}{L}, \quad\text{with } \varepsilon\ll 1.

Then LL−l=11−ε,\dfrac{L}{L-l} = \dfrac{1}{1-\varepsilon}, and for small ε\varepsilon we use the binomial expansion

11−ε  ≈  1+ε+ε2+…\frac{1}{1-\varepsilon} \;\approx\; 1 + \varepsilon + \varepsilon^2 + \ldots

Keeping only the first-order term,

(LL−l)2=1(1−ε)2  ≈  1+2ε.\left(\frac{L}{L-l}\right)^2 = \frac{1}{(1-\varepsilon)^2} \;\approx\; 1 + 2\varepsilon.

Therefore

K2−K1  ≈  12Mv12(1+2ε−1)=12Mv12(2ε)=Mv12ε.K_2 - K_1 \;\approx\; \tfrac12 Mv_1^2 (1 + 2\varepsilon - 1) = \tfrac12 Mv_1^2 (2\varepsilon) = Mv_1^2 \varepsilon.

Substituting ε=lL\varepsilon = \dfrac{l}{L} and v12=2gL(1−cos⁡θ0),v_1^2 = 2gL(1-\cos\theta_0), we get

K2−K1=M[2gL(1−cos⁡θ0)]lL=2Mg(1−cos⁡θ0) l.K_2 - K_1 = M \bigl[2gL(1-\cos\theta_0)\bigr]\frac{l}{L} = 2Mg(1-\cos\theta_0)\,l.

For small angular amplitudes we may use the standard approximation

cos⁡θ0  ≈  1−θ0 22,\cos\theta_0 \;\approx\; 1 - \frac{\theta_0^{\,2}}{2},

so that

1−cos⁡θ0  ≈  θ0 22.1-\cos\theta_0 \;\approx\; \frac{\theta_0^{\,2}}{2}.

Hence

K2−K1  ≈  2Mg(θ0 22)l=Mgθ0 2l.K_2 - K_1 \;\approx\; 2Mg\left(\frac{\theta_0^{\,2}}{2}\right) l = Mg\theta_0^{\,2} l.

Now add the potential-energy change:

W=(K2−K1)+ΔU=Mgθ0 2l+Mg l=Mg l (1+θ0 2).W = (K_2 - K_1) + \Delta U = Mg\theta_0^{\,2}l + Mg\,l = Mg\,l\,(1 + \theta_0^{\,2}).

Thus the work that the person has to do is approximately

W  ≈  Mg l(1+θ0 2).W \;\approx\; Mg\,l\bigl(1 + \theta_0^{\,2}\bigr).

Hence, the correct answer is Option B.

Tagged Angular momentum of particles and rigid bodies. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicAngular momentum of particles and rigid bodies
TypeMultiple choice