RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2020 · 03 SEP S1+4MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2020 Physics question — Refraction at plane surfaces, Snell's law and apparent depth

An observer can see through a small hole on the side of a jar (radius 15 cm) at a point at height of 15 cm from the bottom (see figure). The hole is at a height of 45 cm. When the jar is filled with a liquid up to a height of 30 cm the same observer can see the edge at the bottom of the jar. If the refractive index of the liquid is N100\frac{N}{100}, where N is an integer, the value of N i

Figure for JEE Main 2020 Physics question on Refraction at plane surfaces, Snell's law and apparent depth
SOLUTION

Let us set up a rectangular coordinate frame whose origin is at the inner surface of the wall that contains the hole. The positive xx-direction is taken horizontally towards the opposite wall and the positive yy-direction is taken vertically upward. In this frame

Hole (point HH): xH=0  cm,  yH=45  cmx_H = 0\;\text{cm},\;y_H = 45\;\text{cm}

Bottom edge that finally becomes visible (point BB): xB=30  cm,  yB=0  cmx_B = 30\;\text{cm},\;y_B = 0\;\text{cm} (the diameter of the jar is 2R=30  cm2R = 30\;\text{cm}).

First, observe the empty jar. A straight ray travelling through air from the hole reaches the far wall at a point that is only 15  cm15\;\text{cm} above the bottom. Call this point AA.

xA=30  cm,  yA=15  cmx_A = 30\;\text{cm},\;y_A = 15\;\text{cm}

The line joining H(0,45)H(0,45) to A(30,15)A(30,15) therefore represents the extreme ray the observer can follow when the jar is empty. Its equation is obtained in the usual two-point form

y−45=15−4530−0 (x−0)  .y - 45 = \frac{15-45}{30-0}\,(x-0)\;.

Since the numerator is −30-30 and the denominator is 3030 we have

y−45=−1  x  ,⟹y=45−x  .y - 45 = -1\;x\;,\qquad\Longrightarrow\qquad y = 45 - x\;.

We now fill the jar with liquid up to a height of 30  cm30\;\text{cm}. Hence the liquid-air interface is the horizontal line

y=30  cm  .y = 30\;\text{cm}\;.

Because everything above the liquid is still air, the incident portion of the extreme ray must still run along the same straight line until it meets the interface. Substituting y=30y = 30 in y=45−xy = 45 - x gives the intersection point SS of the ray with the surface:

30=45−xS  ⟹  xS=15  cm  .30 = 45 - x_S \;\Longrightarrow\; x_S = 15\;\text{cm}\;.

Thus

S(15,30).S(15,30).

The path of the complete ray is therefore

H(0,45)  ⟶  S(15,30)  ⟶  B(30,0).H(0,45)\;\longrightarrow\;S(15,30)\;\longrightarrow\;B(30,0).

Segment HSHS lies in air (refractive index n1=1n_1=1) and segment SBSB lies in the liquid (refractive index n2=μn_2=\mu, say).

To apply Snell’s law we need the angles the two segments make with the normal to the interface (the normal is vertical). Let the angle of incidence in air be ii and the angle of refraction in the liquid be rr.

From simple trigonometry, for segment HSHS

ΔxHS=xS−xH=15−0=15  cm,\Delta x_{HS} = x_S - x_H = 15-0 = 15\;\text{cm}, ΔyHS=yS−yH=30−45=−15  cm.\Delta y_{HS} = y_S - y_H = 30-45 = -15\;\text{cm}.

The horizontal component is 15  cm15\;\text{cm} and the vertical component (magnitude) is 15  cm15\;\text{cm}, so

tan⁡i=∣horizontal∣∣vertical∣=1515=1.\tan i = \frac{|\text{horizontal}|}{|\text{vertical}|} = \frac{15}{15} = 1.

We therefore have

i=45∘,sin⁡i=12.i = 45^\circ,\qquad \sin i = \frac{1}{\sqrt2}.

For segment SBSB

ΔxSB=xB−xS=30−15=15  cm,\Delta x_{SB} = x_B - x_S = 30-15 = 15\;\text{cm}, ΔySB=yB−yS=0−30=−30  cm.\Delta y_{SB} = y_B - y_S = 0-30 = -30\;\text{cm}.

Here the horizontal component is 15  cm15\;\text{cm} and the vertical component (magnitude) is 30  cm30\;\text{cm}, giving

tan⁡r=1530=12.\tan r = \frac{15}{30} = \frac12.

Hence the refracted angle satisfies

sin⁡r=tan⁡r1+tan⁡2r=121+(12)2=121+14=1254=1252=15  .\sin r = \frac{\tan r}{\sqrt{1+\tan^2 r}} = \frac{\tfrac12}{\sqrt{1+\left(\tfrac12\right)^2}} = \frac{\tfrac12}{\sqrt{1+\tfrac14}} = \frac{\tfrac12}{\sqrt{\tfrac54}} = \frac{\tfrac12}{\tfrac{\sqrt5}{2}} = \frac1{\sqrt5}\;.

Now we invoke Snell’s law (stated explicitly):

n1 sin⁡i=n2 sin⁡r.n_1\,\sin i = n_2\,\sin r.

With n1=1n_1 = 1 and n2=μn_2 = \mu we write

sin⁡i=μ sin⁡r.\sin i = \mu\,\sin r.

Substituting the values already found, we have

12=μ  15.\frac{1}{\sqrt2} = \mu\;\frac1{\sqrt5}.

Solving for μ\mu gives

μ=12  5=52=2.5=1.5811…  .\mu = \frac{1}{\sqrt2}\;\sqrt5 = \sqrt{\frac52} = \sqrt{2.5} = 1.5811\ldots\;.

The refractive index is therefore approximately 1.581.58. According to the statement of the problem it can be written as N100\dfrac{N}{100}, so

N100≈1.58    ⟹    N=158.\frac{N}{100} \approx 1.58 \;\;\Longrightarrow\;\; N = 158.

Hence, the correct answer is Option 158.

Tagged Refraction at plane surfaces, Snell's law and apparent depth. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicRefraction at plane surfaces, Snell's law and apparent depth
TypeNumerical answer