RankRizz
JEE MAIN 2019 · 12 JAN S2+4 / −1MEDIUMTRANSCRIBED

JEE Main 2019 Physics question — Thin lenses: lens formula, lens maker's formula and power

Formation of real image using a biconvex lens is shown below.

Figure for JEE Main 2019 Physics question on Thin lenses: lens formula, lens maker's formula and power

If the whole set up is immersed in water without disturbing the object and the screen positions, what will one observe on the screen?

SOLUTION

We are given a thin bi-convex lens which, in air, produces a sharp real image of an object on a fixed screen. Let the object distance from the lens be denoted by uu (measured from the lens with the usual sign convention, so in air u<0u<0), and let the screen be at distance vv (so in air v>0v>0). Because the image is sharp, the thin-lens equation in air holds:

1f=1v−1u  .\frac1f=\frac1v-\frac1u\;.

Here ff is the focal length of the lens in air. Now we write the focal length in terms of the radii of curvature of the two spherical surfaces by first stating the Lens-Maker’s formula. For a thin lens whose material has refractive index μg\mu_g and which is placed in a medium of refractive index μm,\mu_m, the formula is

1f=(μgμm−1)(1R1−1R2).\frac1f=\Bigl(\frac{\mu_g}{\mu_m}-1\Bigr)\Bigl(\frac1{R_1}-\frac1{R_2}\Bigr).

For a symmetrical bi-convex lens the first surface has radius R1=+RR_1=+R (center to the right of the surface) and the second has radius R2=−RR_2=-R (center to the left of the surface). Hence in air (where μm=1\mu_m=1)

1fair=(μg−1)(1R−1(−R))=(μg−1)(1R+1R)=2(μg−1)R.\frac1{f_{\text{air}}}=\bigl(\mu_g-1\bigr)\Bigl(\frac1R-\frac1{(-R)}\Bigr) =\bigl(\mu_g-1\bigr)\Bigl(\frac1R+\frac1R\Bigr) =\frac{2(\mu_g-1)}R.

Next we immerse the entire arrangement—lens, object, and screen—into water, taking care not to disturb the positions of the object and screen. The surrounding medium now has refractive index μw  (≈1.33).\mu_w\;( \approx 1.33). The glass of the lens still has index μg  (≈1.50).\mu_g\;( \approx 1.50). Therefore the focal length in water becomes

1fwater=(μgμw−1)(1R−1(−R))=(μgμw−1)2R.\frac1{f_{\text{water}}} =\Bigl(\frac{\mu_g}{\mu_w}-1\Bigr)\Bigl(\frac1R-\frac1{(-R)}\Bigr) =\Bigl(\frac{\mu_g}{\mu_w}-1\Bigr)\frac{2}{R}.

Numerically,

μgμw−1=1.501.33−1≈1.1278−1=0.1278.\frac{\mu_g}{\mu_w}-1 =\frac{1.50}{1.33}-1 \approx1.1278-1 =0.1278.

Comparing this with the value in air, where the factor was μg−1≈0.50,\mu_g-1\approx0.50, we see that

1fwater=0.12780.50  1fair≈0.256  1fair,\frac1{f_{\text{water}}}=\frac{0.1278}{0.50}\;\frac1{f_{\text{air}}} \approx0.256\;\frac1{f_{\text{air}}},

so

fwater≈3.9 fair.f_{\text{water}}\approx3.9\,f_{\text{air}}.

Thus the focal length almost quadruples. Now consider the thin-lens equation again after immersion:

1fwater=1vnew−1usame.\frac1{f_{\text{water}}}=\frac1{v_{\text{new}}}-\frac1{u_{\text{same}}}.

The object distance usameu_{\text{same}} is unchanged because we have not moved the object. The screen, however, is still at the old position vv (the one that satisfied the equation with fairf_{\text{air}}). Because fwaterf_{\text{water}} is very much larger than fair,f_{\text{air}}, the right-hand side calculated with the old uu and vv will no longer equal the new left-hand side. Consequently the equality fails, so the image point shifts away from the screen position.

If one now looks at the screen, the convergence of rays is no longer at the screen surface. Rays arrive either before or after the screen, producing a diffuse blur; a well-defined real image is not obtained at the screen location. To the observer the sharp image simply vanishes.

Therefore, upon immersing the arrangement in water without altering object or screen distances, the sharp real image disappears from the screen.

Hence, the correct answer is Option A.

Tagged Thin lenses: lens formula, lens maker's formula and power. Machine-assigned, so read it as a strong shortlist rather than a verdict.

SubjectPhysics
TopicThin lenses: lens formula, lens maker's formula and power
TypeMultiple choice